Enterprise Intelligence and Data Solutions, Defense Healthcare Management Systems, San Antonio, Texas, USA.
School of Medicine, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, Maryland, USA.
J Palliat Med. 2022 Apr;25(4):549-555. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2021.0041. Epub 2021 Oct 20.
Online opioid conversion calculators (OOCCs) are commonly used to aid conversion between opioids to overcome tolerance, reduce adverse effects, or challenges related to administration. The purpose of this study was to describe and characterize variability among OOCC used by health care practitioners when converting common opioids and doses encountered in the hospice and palliative care setting. We collected 58 quantitative surveys and performed sentiment analysis on 62 qualitative responses from adult learners primarily practicing in the palliative care setting and enrolled in an online palliative care Master of Science program through the University of Maryland, Baltimore, who were asked to perform opioid conversion calculations using realistic patient cases. OOCC have substantial variability leading to a wide range of outputs, which may put patients at risk for opioid-related harm. Assessing participant sentiment toward OOCC showed most participants held a "Negative Sentiment" toward these calculators after the activity. Overall, findings reveal that given the same information, clinicians can come to widely different opioid doses and these differences can be amplified by OOCC. These differences can be particularly dangerous given the higher opioid doses commonly used in the palliative care setting. Considering the significant harm that can arise from an error when converting between opioids, clinicians should avoid the routine use of OOCC in real-world patient care settings. If an OOCC is used, organizations should endorse a specific calculator, provide training and education about the algorithm that supports the calculations, and encourage clinicians to use it only after their own manual calculation, which should be documented in the medical record.
在线阿片类药物换算计算器 (OOCC) 常用于帮助在阿片类药物之间进行转换,以克服耐受性、减少不良反应或与给药相关的挑战。本研究的目的是描述和描述医疗保健从业者在转换姑息治疗和临终关怀环境中常见的阿片类药物和剂量时使用的 OOCC 之间的差异。我们收集了 58 份定量调查,并对主要在姑息治疗环境中执业并通过马里兰大学巴尔的摩分校参加在线姑息治疗硕士科学课程的成年学习者的 62 份定性回复进行了情感分析,他们被要求使用现实患者病例进行阿片类药物转换计算。OOCC 存在很大的差异,导致输出范围很广,这可能使患者面临阿片类药物相关伤害的风险。评估参与者对 OOCC 的态度表明,在活动后,大多数参与者对这些计算器持“负面情绪”。总的来说,研究结果表明,在给定相同信息的情况下,临床医生可以得出广泛不同的阿片类药物剂量,而 OOCC 可以放大这些差异。考虑到姑息治疗环境中常用的阿片类药物剂量较高,这些差异尤其危险。鉴于在阿片类药物之间转换时可能会出现错误,从而导致严重的伤害,临床医生应避免在现实患者护理环境中常规使用 OOCC。如果使用 OOCC,组织应认可特定的计算器,提供支持计算的算法培训和教育,并鼓励临床医生仅在自己手动计算后使用它,该计算应记录在医疗记录中。