Child Health Evaluative Sciences, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Division of Clinical and Metabolic Genetics, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Genet Couns. 2022 Apr;31(2):523-533. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1522. Epub 2021 Oct 21.
Genome sequencing (GS) has demonstrated high diagnostic yield in pediatric patients with complex, clinically heterogeneous presentations. Emerging evidence shows generally favorable experiences for patients and families receiving GS. As a result, implementation of GS in pediatrics is gaining momentum. To inform implementation, we conducted a qualitative study to explore the personal utility of GS for parents of children with medical complexity (CMC). GS was performed at an academic tertiary-care center for CMC for whom a genetic etiology was suspected. Following the return of GS results, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 14 parents about their child's diagnostic journey. Of the children whose parents were interviewed, six children received a diagnosis, two received a possible diagnosis, and six did not receive a diagnosis. A predominantly deductive thematic analysis approach to the interview data was used by applying Kohler's personal utility framework to understand affective, cognitive, behavioral and social impacts of GS. Both the diagnosed and undiagnosed groups experienced enhanced emotion-focused coping (affective). The diagnosed group experienced favorable utility related to knowledge of condition (cognitive) and communication with relatives (behavioral). A domain beyond Kohler's framework related to the presence or absence of GS impact on medical management was also described by parents. The deployment of GS late in the diagnostic odyssey and the limited knowledge available for the rare genetic disorders diagnosed in this cohort appeared to diminish the perceived utility of GS. As GS capabilities continue to evolve at a rapid pace and become available earlier in the diagnostic journey, it is important to consider the impact and timing of testing on parents of CMC.
基因组测序(GS)在具有复杂、临床表现异质性的儿科患者中显示出了高诊断率。新出现的证据表明,接受 GS 的患者和家庭通常有较好的体验。因此,儿科 GS 的实施正在加速。为了提供信息,我们进行了一项定性研究,以探讨 GS 对患有复杂医学疾病(CMC)的儿童的父母的个人效用。GS 是在学术三级保健中心对疑似遗传病因的 CMC 患者进行的。在返回 GS 结果后,对 14 名父母进行了半结构化访谈,了解他们孩子的诊断过程。在接受访谈的孩子中,有 6 名孩子得到了诊断,2 名孩子得到了可能的诊断,6 名孩子没有得到诊断。通过应用科勒的个人效用框架,对访谈数据进行了主要的演绎主题分析,以了解 GS 的情感、认知、行为和社会影响。被诊断和未被诊断的两组都经历了增强的情绪聚焦应对(情感)。诊断组经历了与病情知识(认知)和与亲属沟通(行为)相关的有利效用。父母还描述了科勒框架之外的一个领域,即 GS 对医疗管理的存在或不存在的影响。GS 是在诊断之旅的后期部署的,而且在这个队列中诊断出的罕见遗传疾病的可用知识有限,这似乎降低了人们对 GS 的感知效用。随着 GS 能力的快速发展,并在诊断之旅的早期提供,考虑到对 CMC 父母的测试的影响和时间是很重要的。