Silove D
Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 1986 Sep;20(3):365-9. doi: 10.3109/00048678609158884.
It is commonly believed that patients with agoraphobia have suffered more frequently from aberrant family experiences in childhood. Some authors have described an excess of parental deprivation and others have incriminated parental overprotectiveness. Recent studies have failed to confirm these impressions but, instead, find that agoraphobic patients recall deficits in parental warmth and care during their early years. This report of a Sydney case-control study adds support to the view that parental overprotectiveness in isolation is unlikely to place the child at greater risk of developing agoraphobia in the future. Only when the child experiences a sense of parental neglect and lack of care, either alone or in combination with overprotection, does the risk of agoraphobia in adulthood appear to be increased.
人们普遍认为,广场恐惧症患者童年时期遭受异常家庭经历的情况更为频繁。一些作者描述了过多的父母剥夺,而另一些人则指责父母过度保护。最近的研究未能证实这些观点,相反,发现广场恐惧症患者回忆起早年父母温暖和关怀的缺失。这份悉尼病例对照研究报告支持了这样一种观点,即孤立的父母过度保护不太可能使孩子未来患广场恐惧症的风险更高。只有当孩子单独或与过度保护一起经历父母忽视和缺乏关爱的感觉时,成年后患广场恐惧症的风险才似乎会增加。