Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry and Health Sciences, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Melbourne, Australia.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2023 Aug;32(8):1337-1361. doi: 10.1007/s00787-021-01871-x. Epub 2021 Oct 22.
ADHD is the most common neurodevelopmental disorder presenting to child and adolescent mental health, paediatric, and primary care services. Timely and effective interventions to address core ADHD symptoms and co-occurring problems are a high priority for healthcare and society more widely. While much research has reported on the benefits and adverse effects of different interventions for ADHD, these individual research reports and the reviews, meta-analyses and guidelines summarizing their findings are sometimes inconsistent and difficult to interpret. We have summarized the current evidence and identified several methodological issues and gaps in the current evidence that we believe are important for clinicians to consider when evaluating the evidence and making treatment decisions. These include understanding potential impact of bias such as inadequate blinding and selection bias on study outcomes; the relative lack of high-quality data comparing different treatments and assessing long-term effectiveness, adverse effects and safety for both pharmacological and non-pharmacological treatments; and the problems associated with observational studies, including those based on large national registries and comparing treatments with each other. We highlight key similarities across current international clinical guidelines and discuss the reasons for divergence where these occur. We discuss the integration of these different perspective into a framework for person/family-centered evidence-based practice approach to care that aims to achieve optimal outcomes that prioritize individual strengths and impairments, as well as the personal treatment targets of children and their families. Finally, we consider how access to care for this common and impairing disorder can be improved in different healthcare systems.
注意缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)是儿童和青少年心理健康、儿科和初级保健服务中最常见的神经发育障碍。及时有效地干预以解决 ADHD 的核心症状和共病问题是医疗保健和更广泛的社会的首要任务。虽然大量研究报告了 ADHD 不同干预措施的益处和不良反应,但这些单独的研究报告以及总结其发现的综述、荟萃分析和指南有时并不一致,难以解释。我们总结了当前的证据,并确定了当前证据中存在的几个方法学问题和差距,我们认为临床医生在评估证据和做出治疗决策时需要考虑这些问题。这些问题包括了解潜在的偏倚(如不充分的盲法和选择偏倚)对研究结果的影响;缺乏高质量的数据来比较不同治疗方法,并评估药物和非药物治疗的长期疗效、不良反应和安全性;以及与观察性研究相关的问题,包括基于大型国家登记处和比较不同治疗方法的研究。我们强调了当前国际临床指南之间的关键相似之处,并讨论了出现分歧的原因。我们讨论了将这些不同观点纳入一个以患者/家庭为中心的循证实践方法框架,以实现以个人优势和障碍、儿童及其家庭的个人治疗目标为重点的最佳结果。最后,我们考虑如何在不同的医疗保健系统中改善这种常见且致残疾病的治疗机会。