Dibbets J M, van der Weele L T
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1987 Mar;91(3):193-9. doi: 10.1016/0889-5406(87)90446-x.
This article reports a 10-year longitudinal investigation of symptoms attributed to temporomandibular joint dysfunction in orthodontically treated subjects. The study was designed to test the prevailing assumption that orthodontic therapy is an etiologic factor in inducing TMJ dysfunction. Although the study was prospective in design, several unexpected methodologic complications limited the data analyses. Presumed joint dysfunction symptoms were assessed in orthodontically treated subjects. The presumed symptoms were subsumed under three categories: subjective symptoms, objective symptoms, and x-ray findings. The prevalence of symptoms was analyzed before treatment, 4 years later subsequent to retention, and 10 years after the initiation of the study. Comparisons of symptom frequencies were made between Begg and activator-treated subjects. The results of this investigation led to the following conclusions. In studying temporomandibular joint dysfunction, subjective symptoms, objective symptoms, and x-ray findings should be analyzed separately. Registration of symptoms during orthodontic treatment should probably be attributed to age changes rather than to treatment procedures. Begg Class I and Class II treatments do not reduce the percentages of symptoms registered. Begg Class I and Class II treatments do not affect the incidence of subjective symptoms. Begg Class I and Class II treatments do not affect the incidence of x-ray findings. Begg Class I and Class II treatments create higher percentages of objective symptoms after retention, but not in the long run (10 years). Ten years after the beginning of treatment, the initial differences in symptomatology between activator and Begg children no longer exist.
本文报道了一项针对接受正畸治疗的受试者颞下颌关节功能紊乱症状的为期10年的纵向调查。该研究旨在检验正畸治疗是诱发颞下颌关节功能紊乱的病因这一普遍假设。尽管该研究在设计上是前瞻性的,但一些意外的方法学并发症限制了数据分析。对接受正畸治疗的受试者的假定关节功能紊乱症状进行了评估。假定症状分为三类:主观症状、客观症状和X线检查结果。在治疗前、保持期4年后以及研究开始10年后分析症状的患病率。对采用Begg矫治器和肌激动器治疗的受试者的症状频率进行了比较。本次调查结果得出以下结论。在研究颞下颌关节功能紊乱时,主观症状、客观症状和X线检查结果应分别进行分析。正畸治疗期间症状的记录可能应归因于年龄变化而非治疗程序。Begg I类和II类治疗不会降低记录症状的百分比。Begg I类和II类治疗不影响主观症状的发生率。Begg I类和II类治疗不影响X线检查结果的发生率。Begg I类和II类治疗在保持期后会产生更高比例的客观症状,但从长远来看(10年)并非如此。治疗开始10年后,肌激动器组和Begg矫治器组儿童最初的症状差异不再存在。