Habib Ndema, Steyn Petrus S, Boydell Victoria, Cordero Joanna Paula, Nguyen My Huong, Thwin Soe Soe, Nai Dela, Shamba Donat, Kiarie James
The UNDP/UNFPA/UNICEF/WHO/World Bank Special Programme of Research, Development and Research Training in Human Reproduction (HRP Research), Geneva, Switzerland.
Global Health Centre, Geneva Graduate Institute, Geneva, Switzerland.
Health Serv Outcomes Res Methodol. 2021;21(2):188-205. doi: 10.1007/s10742-020-00221-9. Epub 2020 Nov 24.
An interrupted time series with a parallel control group (ITS-CG) design is a powerful quasi-experimental design commonly used to evaluate the effectiveness of an intervention, on accelerating uptake of useful public health products, and can be used in the presence of regularly collected data. This paper illustrates how a segmented Poisson model that utilizes general estimating equations (GEE) can be used for the ITS-CG study design to evaluate the effectiveness of a complex social accountability intervention on the level and rate of uptake of modern contraception. The intervention was gradually rolled-out over time to targeted intervention communities in Ghana and Tanzania, with control communities receiving standard of care, as per national guidelines. Two ITS GEE segmented regression models are proposed for evaluating of the uptake. The first, a two-segmented model, fits the data collected during pre-intervention and post-intervention excluding that collected during intervention roll-out. The second, a three-segmented model, fits all data including that collected during the roll-out. A much simpler difference-in-difference (DID) GEE Poisson regression model is also illustrated. Mathematical formulation of both ITS-segmented Poisson models and that of the DID Poisson model, interpretation and significance of resulting regression parameters, and accounting for different sources of variation and lags in intervention effect are respectively discussed. Strengths and limitations of these models are highlighted. Segmented ITS modelling remains valuable for studying the effect of intervention interruptions whether gradual changes, over time, in the level or trend in uptake of public health practices are attributed by the introduced intervention. : The Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials registry. : ACTRN12619000378123. : 11-March-2019.
具有平行对照组的中断时间序列(ITS-CG)设计是一种强大的准实验设计,常用于评估干预措施在加速有用公共卫生产品采用方面的有效性,并且可用于存在定期收集数据的情况。本文说明了如何将利用广义估计方程(GEE)的分段泊松模型用于ITS-CG研究设计,以评估一项复杂的社会问责干预措施对现代避孕措施采用水平和采用率的有效性。随着时间的推移,该干预措施逐步推广到加纳和坦桑尼亚的目标干预社区,对照社区按照国家指南接受标准护理。提出了两个用于评估采用情况的ITS GEE分段回归模型。第一个是两段模型,拟合干预前和干预后收集的数据,但不包括干预推广期间收集的数据。第二个是三段模型,拟合所有数据,包括推广期间收集的数据。还说明了一个简单得多的差分(DID)GEE泊松回归模型。分别讨论了两个ITS分段泊松模型和DID泊松模型的数学公式、所得回归参数的解释和意义,以及考虑干预效果的不同变异来源和滞后情况。突出了这些模型的优点和局限性。分段ITS建模对于研究干预中断的影响仍然很有价值,无论公共卫生实践采用水平或趋势随时间的逐渐变化是否归因于引入的干预措施。:澳大利亚新西兰临床试验注册库。:ACTRN12619000378123。:2019年3月11日。