Harley A, Floyd P, Watts T
J Clin Periodontol. 1987 Apr;14(4):221-5. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-051x.1987.tb00970.x.
The purpose of this study was to monitor clinical attachment levels, using a constant force probe, in patients with untreated periodontal disease, and to use darkfield microscopy to monitor changes in subgingival plaque. 10 patients with untreated disease were studied over 12 weeks. The parameters measured at baseline and every 4 weeks were probing depth, attachment level and bleeding. The subgingival microflora of the deepest site in each quadrant was examined by darkfield microscopy, using a Hellber counting chamber, at baseline and 12 weeks. The subgingival plaque from any site which lost more than 2 mm clinical attachment was also sampled and the microflora examined. Analysis of the results shows that 91% of probing depths and attachment levels remained the same or within +/- 1 mm. 3.5% of probing depths and 3.7% of attachment levels became deeper by 2 mm. 6.9% of probing depths and 4.5% of attachment levels became shallower by 2 mm. Only 6 sites out of 1029 showed loss of clinical attachment greater than 2 mm. Darkfield microscopy showed no differences in the proportion of microorganisms at the 6 sites which lost more than 2 mm of clinical attachment, compared with the baseline value. A surprising result was the tendency for probing depths and attachment levels to decrease, especially in deeper pockets. This study showed that none of the parameters monitored, i.e., probing depth, attachment level, bleeding or subgingival microflora, indicated which sites would lose attachment over a 12-week period.
本研究的目的是使用恒力探针监测未经治疗的牙周病患者的临床附着水平,并使用暗视野显微镜监测龈下菌斑的变化。对10例未经治疗的患者进行了为期12周的研究。在基线时以及每4周测量的参数包括探诊深度、附着水平和出血情况。在基线时和12周时,使用海尔伯计数室通过暗视野显微镜检查每个象限最深部位的龈下微生物区系。对临床附着丧失超过2mm的任何部位的龈下菌斑也进行采样并检查其中的微生物区系。结果分析表明,91%的探诊深度和附着水平保持不变或在±1mm范围内。3.5%的探诊深度和3.7%的附着水平加深了2mm。6.9%的探诊深度和4.5%的附着水平变浅了2mm。在1029个部位中,只有6个部位的临床附着丧失超过2mm。暗视野显微镜检查显示,在临床附着丧失超过2mm的6个部位,与基线值相比,微生物比例没有差异。一个令人惊讶的结果是探诊深度和附着水平有降低的趋势,尤其是在较深的牙周袋中。本研究表明,所监测的参数,即探诊深度、附着水平、出血情况或龈下微生物区系,均未表明哪些部位在12周内会丧失附着。