Javier Sarah J, Wu Justina, Smith Donna L, Kanwal Fasiha, Martin Lindsey A, Clark Jack, Midboe Amanda M
Center for Innovation to Implementation (Ci2i), VA Palo Alto Health Care System, Menlo Park, CA, United States.
Center for Innovations in Quality, Effectiveness and Safety (IQuESt), Michael E. DeBakey VA Medical Center, Houston, TX, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2021 Nov 9;5(11):e27748. doi: 10.2196/27748.
Cirrhosis, or scarring of the liver, is a debilitating condition that affects millions of US adults. Early identification, linkage to care, and retention of care are critical for preventing severe complications and death from cirrhosis.
The purpose of this study is to conduct a preimplementation formative evaluation to identify factors that could impact implementation of the Population-Based Cirrhosis Identification and Management System (P-CIMS) in clinics serving patients with cirrhosis. P-CIMS is a web-based informatics tool designed to facilitate patient outreach and cirrhosis care management.
Semistructured interviews were conducted between January and May 2016 with frontline providers in liver disease and primary care clinics at 3 Veterans Health Administration medical centers. A total of 10 providers were interviewed, including 8 physicians and midlevel providers from liver-related specialty clinics and 2 primary care providers who managed patients with cirrhosis. The Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research guided the development of the interview guides. Inductive consensus coding and content analysis were used to analyze transcribed interviews and abstracted coded passages, elucidated themes, and insights.
The following themes and subthemes emerged from the analyses: outer setting: needs and resources for patients with cirrhosis; inner setting: readiness for implementation (subthemes: lack of resources, lack of leadership support), and implementation climate (subtheme: competing priorities); characteristics of individuals: role within clinic; knowledge and beliefs about P-CIMS (subtheme: perceived and realized benefits; useful features; suggestions for improvement); and perceptions of current practices in managing cirrhosis cases (subthemes: preimplementation process for identifying and linking patients to cirrhosis care; structural and social barriers to follow-up). Overall, P-CIMS was viewed as a powerful tool for improving linkage and retention, but its integration in the clinical workflow required leadership support, time, and staffing. Providers also cited the need for more intuitive interface elements to enhance usability.
P-CIMS shows promise as a powerful tool for identifying, linking, and retaining care in patients living with cirrhosis. The current evaluation identified several improvements and advantages of P-CIMS over current care processes and provides lessons for others implementing similar population-based identification and management tools in populations with chronic disease.
肝硬化,即肝脏瘢痕化,是一种影响数百万美国成年人的使人衰弱的病症。早期识别、与医疗服务的衔接以及持续接受治疗对于预防肝硬化的严重并发症和死亡至关重要。
本研究的目的是进行实施前的形成性评估,以确定可能影响在为肝硬化患者服务的诊所中实施基于人群的肝硬化识别与管理系统(P-CIMS)的因素。P-CIMS是一种基于网络的信息学工具,旨在促进患者拓展和肝硬化护理管理。
2016年1月至5月期间,对3家退伍军人健康管理局医疗中心的肝病和初级保健诊所的一线医疗服务提供者进行了半结构化访谈。共采访了10名医疗服务提供者,包括8名来自肝病相关专科诊所的医生和中级医疗服务提供者,以及2名管理肝硬化患者的初级保健提供者。实施研究的综合框架指导了访谈指南的制定。采用归纳共识编码和内容分析来分析转录的访谈内容、提取编码段落、阐明主题和见解。
分析得出以下主题和子主题:外部环境:肝硬化患者的需求和资源;内部环境:实施准备情况(子主题:资源缺乏、缺乏领导支持)以及实施氛围(子主题:相互竞争的优先事项);个人特征:在诊所中的角色;对P-CIMS的知识和信念(子主题:感知和实现的益处;有用的功能;改进建议);以及对当前肝硬化病例管理实践的看法(子主题:识别患者并将其与肝硬化护理相衔接的实施前过程;随访的结构和社会障碍)。总体而言,P-CIMS被视为改善衔接和持续接受治疗的有力工具,但其融入临床工作流程需要领导支持、时间和人员配备。医疗服务提供者还提到需要更直观的界面元素以提高可用性。
P-CIMS有望成为识别、衔接和留住肝硬化患者护理的有力工具。当前的评估确定了P-CIMS相对于当前护理流程的若干改进和优势,并为其他在慢性病患者群体中实施类似的基于人群的识别和管理工具的人提供了经验教训。