Parsons L G, Thomas L G, Southard G L, Woodall I R, Jones B J
J Clin Periodontol. 1987 Aug;14(7):381-5. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-051x.1987.tb01540.x.
Sanguinaria extract (sanguinaria) solutions were evaluated in 44 subjects in a 2-week, no oral hygiene study as a 300 micrograms/ml manual rinse, and the results compared to supragingival irrigation with 22.5 micrograms/ml sanguinaria concentration and supragingival irrigation with water. Both the manual use of sanguinaria and supragingival irrigation of dilute sanguinaria produced significantly less plaque growth than supragingival irrigation with deionized water. In terms of % changes from baseline, manual rinsing and supragingival irrigation with sanguinaria limited plaque growth to 17.7% and 24.2%, respectively, while irrigation with water had a 51.5% growth. For gingivitis, control supragingival irrigation with sanguinarine and with water were statistically different from manual rinsing with sanguinaria. Compared to baseline, the groups irrigating with sanguinaria and with water had gingivitis reductions of 68.7% and 73.3%, respectively, while manual rinsing with sanguinaria had a 29.6% reduction. The results suggest that dilute solutions of sanguinaria delivered via rinsing or supragingival irrigation are effective in controlling plaque as an additional benefit to the use of supragingival irrigation to control gingivitis. Supragingival irrigation with sanguinaria as part of a home care routine for patients with plaque and gingivitis is suggested.
在一项为期两周、不进行口腔卫生护理的研究中,对44名受试者使用血根碱提取物(血根碱)溶液进行300微克/毫升的手动冲洗,并将结果与使用浓度为22.5微克/毫升的血根碱进行龈上冲洗以及用清水进行龈上冲洗的结果进行比较。与用去离子水进行龈上冲洗相比,手动使用血根碱和用稀释血根碱进行龈上冲洗产生的菌斑生长明显更少。就相对于基线的百分比变化而言,用血液根碱进行手动冲洗和龈上冲洗分别将菌斑生长限制在17.7%和24.2%,而用水冲洗则有51.5%的生长。对于牙龈炎,用血根碱和用水进行对照龈上冲洗与用血根碱进行手动冲洗在统计学上有差异。与基线相比,用血根碱和用水冲洗的组的牙龈炎分别减少了68.7%和73.3%,而用血液根碱进行手动冲洗减少了29.6%。结果表明,通过冲洗或龈上冲洗递送的稀释血根碱溶液在控制菌斑方面是有效的,这是龈上冲洗用于控制牙龈炎的额外益处。建议将用血根碱进行龈上冲洗作为有菌斑和牙龈炎患者家庭护理常规的一部分。