Savage Sharon A, Lampe Leonie F, Nickels Lyndsey
School of Psychological Sciences, The University of Newcastle, Callaghan, Australia.
Department of Cognitive Science, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia.
Neuropsychol Rehabil. 2023 Mar;33(2):193-225. doi: 10.1080/09602011.2021.1993934. Epub 2021 Nov 13.
Word retraining techniques can improve picture naming of treated items in people with semantic dementia (SD). The utility of this, however, has been questioned given the propensity for under- and overgeneralization errors in naming in SD. Few studies have investigated the occurrence of such errors. This study examined whether, following tailored word retraining: (1) misuse of words increases, (2) the type of naming errors changes, and/or (3) clarity of communication is reduced. Performance on trained and untrained word naming from nine participants with SD who completed a word retraining programme were analysed. Responses from baseline and post-intervention assessments were coded for misuse (i.e., trained word produced for another target item), error type, and communication clarity. All participants showed significant improvement for trained vocabulary. There was no significant increase in misuse of words, with such errors occurring rarely. At a group level, there was an increased tendency toward omission errors for untrained items, and a reduction in semantically related responses. However, this did not impact on clarity scores with no consistent change across participants. In sum, we found no negative impacts following tailored word retraining, providing further evidence of the benefit of these programmes for individuals with SD.
词汇再训练技术可以改善语义性痴呆(SD)患者对经过治疗的物品的图片命名能力。然而,鉴于SD患者在命名时容易出现泛化不足和过度泛化错误,其效用受到了质疑。很少有研究调查此类错误的发生情况。本研究考察了在进行针对性的词汇再训练后:(1)词汇误用是否增加,(2)命名错误的类型是否改变,和/或(3)沟通清晰度是否降低。对九名完成词汇再训练计划的SD患者在训练和未训练词汇命名方面的表现进行了分析。对基线和干预后评估的反应进行编码,以确定误用情况(即,为另一个目标项目生成的训练词汇)、错误类型和沟通清晰度。所有参与者在训练词汇方面都有显著改善。词汇误用没有显著增加,此类错误很少发生。在组水平上,未训练项目的遗漏错误倾向增加,语义相关反应减少。然而,这并未影响清晰度得分,参与者之间没有一致的变化。总之,我们发现针对性的词汇再训练没有负面影响,这为这些计划对SD患者的益处提供了进一步的证据。