Department of History, Birkbeck College, University of London, London, United Kingdom.
The Medical Intensive Care Unit, National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, London, United Kingdom.
Eur Neurol. 2022;85(2):162-168. doi: 10.1159/000519833. Epub 2021 Nov 17.
The neurological and psychological manifestations of trauma, confinement, and terror became apparent throughout Europe as soldiers were evacuated from the trenches of the Western Front. The response in the UK evolved as a result of the experience of medical staff embedded with the troops in base hospitals and the philosophy of those treating returned soldiers in specialist establishment. There were widely disparate approaches to the management encompassing simple supportive care, a psychanalytic approach and radical electric shock therapy. The latter was partially driven by the Queen Square experience in the UK but was also concurrently widely pursued throughout Europe. With experience, care was increasingly undertaken close to the front lines using a philosophy of immediacy and expectation of recovery. Post-war analysis was startlingly unsympathetic, yet the experiences and management of shell shock have guided psychiatric and medical understanding of functional illness and post-traumatic stress over the subsequent century. In this historical review, we have sought to present features of the UK response to the neurological manifestations of trauma, the way in which these changed as the war proceeded and the political and medical response in the aftermath of war.
创伤、监禁和恐怖的神经和心理表现在欧洲各地都很明显,因为士兵们从西线的战壕中被撤离。英国的反应是由于医务人员与部队一起驻扎在基地医院的经验,以及专门机构中治疗返回士兵的理念演变而来的。对于这种管理,有广泛不同的方法,包括简单的支持性护理、精神分析方法和激进的电击疗法。后者部分是由英国皇后广场的经验推动的,但也同时在整个欧洲广泛推行。随着经验的积累,护理越来越多地在前线进行,采用即时性和康复预期的理念。战后的分析令人惊讶地缺乏同情心,但弹震症的经历和管理指导了精神病学和医学对功能性疾病和创伤后应激的理解,这在随后的一个世纪中一直如此。在本次历史回顾中,我们试图呈现英国对创伤性神经表现的反应的特点,以及随着战争的进行这些反应如何变化,以及战后的政治和医学反应。