Department of Vascular Surgery, University of Maryland, Baltimore, Md; Vascular Service, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Baltimore, Md; Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, Fla.
Department of Bioengineering, George Mason University, Fairfax, Va.
J Vasc Surg. 2022 Apr;75(4):1311-1322.e3. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2021.10.056. Epub 2021 Nov 15.
The current risk assessment for patients with carotid atherosclerosis relies primarily on measuring the degree of stenosis. More reliable risk stratification could improve patient selection for targeted treatment. We have developed and validated a model to predict for major adverse neurologic events (MANE; stroke, transient ischemic attack, amaurosis fugax) that incorporates a combination of plaque morphology, patient demographics, and patient clinical information.
We enrolled 221 patients with asymptomatic carotid stenosis of any severity who had undergone computed tomography angiography at baseline and ≥6 months later. The images were analyzed for carotid plaque morphology (plaque geometry and tissue composition). The data were partitioned into training and validation cohorts. Of the 221 patients, 190 had complete records available and were included in the present analysis. The training cohort was used to develop the best model for predicting MANE, incorporating the patient and plaque features. First, single-variable correlation and unsupervised clustering were performed. Next, several multivariable models were implemented for the response variable of MANE. The best model was selected by optimizing the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) and Cohen's kappa statistic. The model was validated using the sequestered data to demonstrate generalizability.
A total of 62 patients had experienced a MANE during follow-up. Unsupervised clustering of the patient and plaque features identified single-variable predictors of MANE. Multivariable predictive modeling showed that a combination of the plaque features at baseline (matrix, intraplaque hemorrhage [IPH], wall thickness, plaque burden) with the clinical features (age, body mass index, lipid levels) best predicted for MANE (AUC, 0.79), In contrast, the percent diameter stenosis performed the worst (AUC, 0.55). The strongest single variable for discriminating between patients with and without MANE was IPH, and the most predictive model was produced when IPH was considered with wall remodeling. The selected model also performed well for the validation dataset (AUC, 0.64) and maintained superiority compared with percent diameter stenosis (AUC, 0.49).
A composite of plaque geometry, plaque tissue composition, patient demographics, and clinical information predicted for MANE better than did the traditionally used degree of stenosis alone for those with carotid atherosclerosis. Implementing this predictive model in the clinical setting could help identify patients at high risk of MANE.
目前,对颈动脉粥样硬化患者的风险评估主要依赖于测量狭窄程度。更可靠的风险分层可以改善针对特定治疗的患者选择。我们已经开发并验证了一种模型,用于预测主要不良神经事件(MANE;中风、短暂性脑缺血发作、一过性黑矇),该模型结合了斑块形态、患者人口统计学特征和患者临床信息。
我们纳入了 221 例无症状性颈动脉狭窄程度不同的患者,这些患者在基线时和之后≥6 个月进行了计算机断层血管造影检查。对颈动脉斑块形态(斑块几何形状和组织成分)进行了分析。将数据分为训练队列和验证队列。在 221 例患者中,有 190 例有完整的记录,这些患者被纳入了本分析。在训练队列中,我们使用了患者和斑块特征来开发预测 MANE 的最佳模型。首先,进行了单变量相关性和无监督聚类分析。然后,针对 MANE 这一应答变量实施了几种多变量模型。通过优化接收者操作特征曲线(AUC)和 Cohen's kappa 统计量来选择最佳模型。使用分离的数据进行验证,以证明其可推广性。
在随访期间,共有 62 例患者发生了 MANE。对患者和斑块特征的无监督聚类分析确定了 MANE 的单变量预测因子。多变量预测模型显示,基线时斑块特征(基质、斑块内出血[IPH]、管壁厚度、斑块负荷)与临床特征(年龄、体重指数、血脂水平)的组合可以很好地预测 MANE(AUC,0.79),而直径狭窄程度的百分比表现最差(AUC,0.55)。区分有无 MANE 患者的最强单变量是 IPH,当考虑到壁重构时,最具预测性的模型是 IPH。所选模型在验证数据集上也表现良好(AUC,0.64),与直径狭窄程度相比具有优势(AUC,0.49)。
斑块几何形状、斑块组织成分、患者人口统计学特征和临床信息的组合预测 MANE 的能力优于传统上仅使用颈动脉粥样硬化患者的狭窄程度。在临床环境中实施这种预测模型可以帮助识别 MANE 风险较高的患者。