Swansea University Medical School, Swansea University, UK.
Swansea University Medical School, Swansea University, UK.
Soc Sci Med. 2022 Jan;292:114566. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114566. Epub 2021 Nov 14.
There was a highly publicised cluster of at least ten suicides in South Wales, United Kingdom, in 2007-2008. We carried out a qualitative descriptive study using cross-case thematic analysis to investigate the experiences and narratives of eight individuals who lived in the area where the cluster occurred and who survived an episode of near-fatal self-harm at the time of the cluster. Interviews were conducted from 01.01.2015 to 31.12.2015. All interviewees denied that the other deaths in the area had affected their own suicidal behaviour. However, in other sections of the interviews they spoke about the cluster contributing to difficulties they were experiencing at the time, including damage to social relationships, feelings of loss and being out of control. When asked about support, the interviewees emphasized the importance of counselling, which they would have found helpful but in most cases did not receive, even in the case of close contacts of individuals who had died. The findings suggest that effective prevention messaging must be subtle, since those affected may not be explicitly aware of or acknowledge the imitative aspects of their behaviour. This could be related to stigma attached to suicidal behaviour in a cluster context. Lessons for prevention include changing the message from asking if people 'have been affected by' the suicide deaths to emphasising the preventability of suicide, and directly reaching out to individuals rather than relying on people to come forward.
2007-2008 年,英国南威尔士发生了一起至少 10 人自杀的高知名度集群事件。我们使用跨案例主题分析进行了定性描述性研究,以调查在集群发生时居住在该地区并在集群期间经历过濒死自杀事件的 8 个人的经历和叙述。访谈于 2015 年 1 月 1 日至 12 月 31 日进行。所有受访者均否认该地区其他死亡事件影响了他们自己的自杀行为。然而,在访谈的其他部分,他们谈到集群事件导致他们当时面临的困难,包括社交关系受损、失落感和失控感。当被问及支持时,受访者强调咨询的重要性,他们会觉得这很有帮助,但在大多数情况下,他们并没有得到咨询,即使是那些与死者有密切联系的人也没有得到咨询。研究结果表明,有效的预防信息必须是微妙的,因为那些受影响的人可能没有明确意识到或承认他们行为的模仿方面。这可能与集群环境中自杀行为的耻辱感有关。预防的经验教训包括将信息从询问人们“是否受到自杀死亡的影响”转变为强调自杀的可预防性,并直接接触个人,而不是依赖人们主动前来。