Fiacco Serena, Arpagaus Carla, Mernone Laura, Ehlert Ulrike
Chair of Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, Psychological Institute, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
University Research Priority Program Dynamics of Healthy Aging Research Priority Program, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Front Glob Womens Health. 2021 Aug 30;2:740894. doi: 10.3389/fgwh.2021.740894. eCollection 2021.
Female intrasexual competition (ISC) represents a unique form of social interaction. It describes behaviors primarily applied to enhance a woman's ability to outcompete other women. Previous research suggests that female ISC is influenced by personality characteristics and sex hormones. Although these factors most likely interact to predict female ISC, no previous study has investigated those factors in parallel in order to link theories from social psychology and biology. Women at the end of the reproductive lifespan represent the ideal study population, as they allow for a controlled hormonal environment. Healthy pre- ( = 53) and postmenopausal ( = 56) women were classified according to the Stages of Reproductive Aging Workshop (STRAW+10) criteria. In the follicular phase (for premenopausal women) or on a random day (for postmenopausal women), questionnaires were administered to assess the general tendency to compete intrasexually and the tendency to compete on appearance, attention/interpersonal success, and competence. Additionally, personality characteristics (neuroticism, extraversion, openness, agreeableness, conscientiousness, and self-esteem) were assessed. On the same day, each subject provided an 8 a.m. saliva sample for estradiol, testosterone, progesterone, and dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate. -tests tested for between-group differences and separate multiple linear regression models tested for an effect of continuous hormone levels and personality characteristics on ISC. Further models were run, testing for an interaction with menopausal stage. No group differences in ISC were evident (all > 0.05). In premenopausal women, estradiol levels positively predicted the competition for attention (β = 2.103, = 0.022). In postmenopausal women, self-esteem predicted the tendency to compete overall (β = -0.208, < 0.001), on appearance (β = -0.061, = 0.01), on competence (β = -0.087, < 0.001), and on attention/interpersonal success (β = -0.060, = 0.01). These results, though cross-sectional, suggest that women continue to compete intrasexually in postmenopause, giving rise to new questions about the function of female ISC. If confirmed, the findings will indicate that hormones guide competitiveness in fertile women, whereas self-esteem accounts for individual differences in competitiveness post-reproduction. Particularly the function of postmenopausal ISC warrants further investigation.
女性内性竞争(ISC)是一种独特的社会互动形式。它描述的行为主要用于增强女性在与其他女性竞争中胜出的能力。先前的研究表明,女性ISC受人格特征和性激素影响。尽管这些因素很可能相互作用以预测女性ISC,但此前尚无研究同时考察这些因素,以便将社会心理学和生物学的理论联系起来。处于生殖寿命末期的女性是理想的研究人群,因为她们的激素环境可控。根据生殖衰老研讨会(STRAW+10)标准,对53名健康的绝经前女性和56名绝经后女性进行了分类。在卵泡期(针对绝经前女性)或随机一天(针对绝经后女性),发放问卷以评估内性竞争的总体倾向以及在外表、注意力/人际成功和能力方面的竞争倾向。此外,还评估了人格特征(神经质、外向性、开放性、宜人性、尽责性和自尊)。在同一天,每位受试者于上午8点提供唾液样本,用于检测雌二醇、睾酮、孕酮和硫酸脱氢表雄酮。t检验用于检验组间差异,单独的多元线性回归模型用于检验连续激素水平和人格特征对ISC的影响。还运行了进一步的模型,检验与绝经阶段的相互作用。ISC方面未发现组间差异(所有p>0.05)。在绝经前女性中,雌二醇水平正向预测对注意力的竞争(β=2.103,p=0.022)。在绝经后女性中,自尊预测总体竞争倾向(β=-0.208,p<0.001)、在外表方面的竞争倾向(β=-0.061,p=0.01)、在能力方面的竞争倾向(β=-0.087,p<0.001)以及在注意力/人际成功方面的竞争倾向(β=-0.060,p=0.01)。这些结果虽然是横断面的,但表明女性在绝经后仍继续进行内性竞争,这引发了关于女性ISC功能的新问题。如果得到证实,这些发现将表明激素引导育龄女性的竞争力,而自尊则解释了生殖后竞争力的个体差异。特别是绝经后ISC的功能值得进一步研究。