Bartelink Eric J, Clinkinbeard Shannon, Spessard Crystal, Kilmartin Aoife, Spangler William L
Human Identification Laboratory, Department of Anthropology, California State University-Chico, Chico, California, USA.
Department of Anthropology, San Diego State University, San Diego, California, USA.
J Forensic Sci. 2022 Mar;67(2):756-765. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.14948. Epub 2021 Nov 23.
This case study demonstrates how animal abuse investigations can benefit from collaboration between forensic anthropologists and veterinary pathologists, especially in investigations involving trauma assessment of skeletal remains. In 2009, four deceased dogs were excavated from a residential property in conjunction with a case of suspected animal abuse. The decomposed remains were skeletonized to permit assessment of biological profiles, individualization, and trauma analysis. Each dog was identified based on their sex, age-at-death, fur coloration patterns, and through investigative information. The analysis conducted by forensic anthropologists in collaboration with a veterinary pathologist revealed evidence of perimortem blunt force trauma on all four skeletons. The distribution and severity of the injuries, including fractures concentrated mainly on the axial skeleton (i.e., skull, thorax, and vertebral column) and pelvis, are consistent with documented cases of non-accidental injury (NAI) reported in the literature. Healed rib fractures were also noted on one of the dogs, and likely occurred a few weeks prior to death, further supporting a diagnosis of NAI. The skeletal trauma findings were inconsistent with the dog owner's account of how each dog had died and were instrumental in resolving the investigation.
本案例研究展示了虐待动物案件的调查如何受益于法医人类学家和兽医病理学家之间的合作,特别是在涉及骨骼遗骸创伤评估的调查中。2009年,从一处住宅挖掘出四只死亡的狗,该案件涉嫌虐待动物。已腐烂的遗骸已变成骨架,以便进行生物学特征评估、个体识别和创伤分析。每只狗根据其性别、死亡年龄、毛色图案以及调查信息进行识别。法医人类学家与兽医病理学家合作进行的分析显示,所有四具骨架上均有生前钝器伤的证据。损伤的分布和严重程度,包括主要集中在中轴骨骼(即头骨、胸部和脊柱)和骨盆的骨折,与文献中报道的非意外伤害(NAI)记录案例一致。在其中一只狗身上还发现了愈合的肋骨骨折,可能发生在死亡前几周,这进一步支持了非意外伤害的诊断。骨骼创伤的发现与狗主人对每只狗死因的描述不一致,并且对解决该调查起到了重要作用。