Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Escola Paulista de Medicina, Division of Plastic Surgery - São Paulo (SP), Brazil.
Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Escola Paulista de Medicina, Translational Surgery Graduate Program - São Paulo (SP), Brazil.
Rev Assoc Med Bras (1992). 2021 Jul;67(7):1069-1074. doi: 10.1590/1806-9282.20210186.
This study aimed to compare the publications authored by plastic surgeons with those from other specialties' surgeons on patient-reported outcomes of oncoplastic surgery.
A review was carried out on the Medline database, emcompassing five years (2015-2020). Studies about partial breast reconstruction after conservative treatment, immediate or delayed, by any technique, which presented patient-reported outcomes, were included.
We found 292 articles, from which 142 met the eligibility criteria. Publications were stratified into groups 1 (plastic surgeons) and 2 (other surgical specialties), and also into groups A (only plastic surgeons), B (only other specialties) and C (both), and compared statistically. Most publications (60.6%) were attributed to specialties other than plastic surgery. Nineteen percent had only plastic surgeons as authors, 50% only other specialties' surgeons, and 31% had both. There was no difference between groups regarding the impact factor of the journals in any of the stratifications, and the majority was published in journals with impact factor ≤2. CONCLUSION: In the last years, surgeons from specialties other than plastic surgery published more about the results of the oncoplastic surgery reported by the patients. There was no statistical difference between the groups regarding the impact factor of the journals.
本研究旨在比较整形外科医生和其他外科专业医生发表的关于肿瘤整形手术患者报告结局的文献。
对 Medline 数据库进行了回顾，涵盖了五年（2015-2020 年）。纳入了关于任何技术的保乳治疗后即刻或延迟的部分乳房重建的研究，这些研究均报告了患者报告的结局。
我们发现了 292 篇文章，其中 142 篇符合入选标准。出版物分为 1 组（整形外科医生）和 2 组（其他外科专业），以及 A 组（仅整形外科医生）、B 组（仅其他专业）和 C 组（两者均有），并进行了统计学比较。大多数出版物（60.6%）来自于整形外科以外的专业。19%的出版物只有整形外科医生作为作者，50%只有其他专业的外科医生，31%两者都有。在任何分层中，期刊的影响因子都没有组间差异，而且大多数发表在影响因子≤2 的期刊上。
在过去几年中，来自整形外科以外的专业的外科医生发表了更多关于肿瘤整形手术患者报告结果的文章。在期刊影响因子方面，各组之间没有统计学差异。
