Department of Endocrinology and Nutrition. Hospital Regional Universitario de Málaga. Universidad de Málaga. Instituto de Investigación Biomédica de Málaga (IBIMA).
Department of Pneumology. Hospital Regional Universitario de Málaga. Universidad de Málaga. Instituto de Investigación Biomédica de Málaga (IBIMA).
Nutr Hosp. 2022 Mar 29;39(2):376-382. doi: 10.20960/nh.03836.
Introduction: few studies have evaluated body composition (BC) through different techniques, and the degree of agreement between them in adults with cystic fibrosis (CF). Objectives: to describe BC using techniques to assess nutritional status and to test their concordance in CF. Methods: a cross-sectional study in CF patients in a clinically stable situation. Nutritional assessment was performed using skinfold measurement (SM) and densitometry (DXA). Fat-free mass index (FFMI) was also determined. The diagnosis of malnutrition was established if body mass index (BMI) < 18.5 kg/m2. Fat-free mass (FFM) malnutrition was diagnosed when FFMI was < 17 kg/m2 in males and < 15 kg/m2 in females (FFMI: fat-free mass in kg/height in m2). Results: forty-one patients were studied (twenty-two females, 53.7 %); median age was 29.8 (interquartile range, 20.9-33.7); BMI was 21.6 (19.8-23.0). Only four (9.8 %) patients had a BMI < 18.5. By DXA, FFM (kg) results were: median, 52.8 (47.8-56.9) with FFMI of 17.9 (16.7-19.3) in males and 36.7 (33.1-38.9) in females, FFMI of 14.7 (14.2-15.8). Twenty (48.6 %) patients presented FFM malnutrition, with 16.7 % of males and 59.1 % of females being affected. By SM, the FFMI was 18.7 (17.2-20.0) in males and 14.9 (14.2-15.8) in females; moreover, sixteen (39.1 %) patients presented malnutrition of FFM, with 20.8 % of males and 61.8 % of females being affected. For FFM (kg), a high concordance was obtained between SM and DXA (intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.950); likewise when they were compared by applying the ESPEN criteria for FFM malnutrition. However, when the techniques were compared to classify malnutrition according to FFMI, the kappa coefficient was only moderate (k = 0.440). The mean difference between FFM by DXA and SM was +1.44 ± 0.62 kg in favor of SM, with greater dispersion as FFM increased. Conclusions: the prevalence of FFM malnutrition is high in adult CF patients, despite a normal BMI, especially in females. Notwithstanding the good statistical agreement between SM and DXA, concordance was moderate. Therefore, DXA remains the technique of choice, and SM may be used when the former is not available.
很少有研究通过不同的技术评估人体成分(BC),并且在囊性纤维化(CF)成人中,这些技术之间的一致性程度也不清楚。目的:使用评估营养状况的技术描述 BC,并检验它们在 CF 中的一致性。方法:对临床稳定的 CF 患者进行横断面研究。使用皮褶测量(SM)和密度测定(DXA)进行营养评估。还确定了无脂肪质量指数(FFMI)。如果 BMI <18.5kg/m2,则诊断为营养不良。如果男性的 FFMI<17kg/m2,女性的 FFMI<15kg/m2(FFMI:kg/m2 的无脂肪质量),则诊断为无脂肪质量营养不良。结果:共研究了 41 名患者(22 名女性,53.7%);中位年龄为 29.8(四分位距,20.9-33.7);BMI 为 21.6(19.8-23.0)。只有 4 名(9.8%)患者 BMI<18.5。根据 DXA,FFM(kg)的结果为:中位数 52.8(47.8-56.9),男性 FFMI 为 17.9(16.7-19.3),女性为 36.7(33.1-38.9),FFMI 为 14.7(14.2-15.8)。20 名(48.6%)患者出现 FFM 营养不良,其中男性 16.7%,女性 59.1%。通过 SM,男性的 FFMI 为 18.7(17.2-20.0),女性的 FFMI 为 14.9(14.2-15.8);此外,16 名(39.1%)患者出现 FFM 营养不良,其中男性 20.8%,女性 61.8%。对于 FFM(kg),SM 和 DXA 之间具有很高的一致性(组内相关系数为 0.950);同样,当根据 FFM 营养不良的 ESPEN 标准进行比较时也是如此。然而,当根据 FFMI 来比较这些技术以分类营养不良时,kappa 系数仅为中度(k=0.440)。DXA 与 SM 测量的 FFM 之间的平均差异为+1.44±0.62kg,有利于 SM,并且随着 FFM 的增加,离散度也更大。结论:尽管 BMI 正常,但成年 CF 患者中 FFM 营养不良的患病率很高,尤其是女性。尽管 SM 和 DXA 之间具有良好的统计学一致性,但一致性为中度。因此,DXA 仍然是首选技术,当无法使用前者时,可以使用 SM。