Division of Child Neurology and Center for Pediatric Bioethics, Nationwide Children's Hospital - The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio.
Pediatr Neurol. 2022 Jan;126:120-124. doi: 10.1016/j.pediatrneurol.2021.10.015. Epub 2021 Oct 30.
Nazi Germany surrendered to the Allies on May 8, 1945. Six months later, the Allies tried the surviving leaders of Nazi Germany at the first Nuremberg trial. Later, the United States conducted 12 additional trials. The first one, The Unites States of America versus Karl Brandt et al., has been dubbed the Doctors' Trial. During the trial, the prosecution relied on the testimony of Dr. Andrew Ivy and Dr. Leo Alexander. At the end of the trial, Judge Sebring enunciated 10 principles needed to conduct human subject research-the Nuremberg Code. Authorship of the Code has been the subject of dispute, with both Ivy and Alexander claiming sole authorship.
In the summer of 2017, I visited Duke University Medical Center's Archives and surveyed the contents of boxes labeled "Alexander's papers." I also explored online databases with information on the Doctors' Trial. Pertinent documents were compared across collections, and against scholarly works on the topic.
Box 3 of Alexander's papers at Duke University Medical Center's Archives contains a three-page document with six principles that, nearly word for word, were included in what is known as the Nuremberg Code. Alexander's name and appointment are typed at the end of the document.
Although the Nuremberg Code is likely to have been an unplanned collaboration among members of the prosecuting team and the judges, I present evidence suggesting that Alexander drafted the blueprint and was the main contributor to the final version of the Code.
纳粹德国于 1945 年 5 月 8 日向盟军投降。六个月后,盟军在纽伦堡审判中审判了幸存的纳粹德国领导人。后来,美国又进行了 12 次额外的审判。第一次审判,即美国诉 Karl Brandt 等人案,被称为“医生审判”。在审判过程中,控方依赖于安德鲁·艾维(Andrew Ivy)博士和利奥·亚历山大(Leo Alexander)博士的证词。审判结束时,塞布林法官阐述了进行人体研究所需的 10 项原则——纽伦堡法典。法典的作者一直存在争议,艾维和亚历山大都声称自己是唯一的作者。
2017 年夏天,我访问了杜克大学医学中心的档案馆,调查了标有“亚历山大论文”的盒子的内容。我还在有关于医生审判的信息的在线数据库中进行了探索。相关文件在各收藏中进行了比较,并与该主题的学术著作进行了比较。
杜克大学医学中心档案馆的亚历山大论文第 3 盒包含一份三页的文件,其中有六项原则,几乎逐字逐句地包含在所谓的纽伦堡法典中。文件末尾打印有亚历山大的名字和任命。
尽管纽伦堡法典很可能是起诉团队成员和法官之间的一次意外合作,但我提供的证据表明,亚历山大起草了蓝图,并对法典的最终版本做出了主要贡献。