Fan Yubo, Zhang Dongqing, Banalagay Rueben, Wang Jianing, Noble Jack H, Dawant Benoit M
Vanderbilt University, Department of Computer Science, Nashville, Tennessee, United States.
Google LLC, Mountain View, California, United States.
J Med Imaging (Bellingham). 2021 Nov;8(6):064002. doi: 10.1117/1.JMI.8.6.064002. Epub 2021 Nov 24.
Robust and accurate segmentation methods for the intracochlear anatomy (ICA) are a critical step in the image-guided cochlear implant programming process. We have proposed an active shape model (ASM)-based method and a deep learning (DL)-based method for this task, and we have observed that the DL method tends to be more accurate than the ASM method while the ASM method tends to be more robust. We propose a DL-based U-Net-like architecture that incorporates ASM segmentation into the network. A quantitative analysis is performed on a dataset that consists of 11 cochlea specimens for which a segmentation ground truth is available. To qualitatively evaluate the robustness of the method, an experienced expert is asked to visually inspect and grade the segmentation results on a clinical dataset made of 138 image volumes acquired with conventional CT scanners and of 39 image volumes acquired with cone beam CT (CBCT) scanners. Finally, we compare training the network (1) first with the ASM results, and then fine-tuning it with the ground truth segmentation and (2) directly with the specimens with ground truth segmentation. Quantitative and qualitative results show that the proposed method increases substantially the robustness of the DL method while having only a minor detrimental effect (though not significant) on its accuracy. Expert evaluation of the clinical dataset shows that by incorporating the ASM segmentation into the DL network, the proportion of good segmentation cases increases from 60/177 to 119/177 when training only with the specimens and increases from 129/177 to 151/177 when pretraining with the ASM results. A hybrid ASM and DL-based segmentation method is proposed to segment the ICA in CT and CBCT images. Our results show that combining DL and ASM methods leads to a solution that is both robust and accurate.
用于耳蜗内解剖结构(ICA)的强大且准确的分割方法是图像引导人工耳蜗编程过程中的关键一步。我们针对此任务提出了一种基于主动形状模型(ASM)的方法和一种基于深度学习(DL)的方法,并且我们观察到DL方法往往比ASM方法更准确,而ASM方法往往更稳健。我们提出了一种类似U-Net的基于DL的架构,该架构将ASM分割纳入网络。对一个由11个耳蜗标本组成的数据集进行了定量分析,这些标本有分割的真实标注。为了定性评估该方法的稳健性,邀请一位经验丰富的专家对由138个使用传统CT扫描仪获取的图像体积和39个使用锥束CT(CBCT)扫描仪获取的图像体积组成的临床数据集的分割结果进行视觉检查和评分。最后,我们比较了(1)先用ASM结果训练网络,然后用真实分割进行微调,以及(2)直接用带有真实分割的标本训练网络这两种方式。定量和定性结果表明,所提出的方法在对DL方法的准确性只有轻微不利影响(尽管不显著)的情况下,大幅提高了其稳健性。对临床数据集的专家评估表明,通过将ASM分割纳入DL网络,仅使用标本训练时,良好分割病例的比例从60/177增加到119/177,先用ASM结果预训练时,从129/177增加到151/177。提出了一种基于ASM和DL的混合分割方法来分割CT和CBCT图像中的ICA。我们的结果表明,将DL和ASM方法相结合可得到一种既稳健又准确的解决方案。