MS Genetic Counseling Program, The University of North Carolina at Greensboro, Greensboro, North Carolina, USA.
Department of Women's Health, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina, USA.
J Genet Couns. 2022 Jun;31(3):722-734. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1539. Epub 2021 Dec 2.
Stress and anxiety are significant concerns for practicing genetic counselors as well as genetic counseling students and can have downstream effects on patient care. Prior research suggests graduate-level training in self-awareness practices such as self-care, reflection, and mindfulness could have lasting effects for genetic counselors, their patients, and the profession as a whole. This mixed-methods study assessed self-awareness among 154 genetic counseling graduate students using the Self-Reflection and Insight Scale (SRIS), the Mindfulness Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS), and self-described experiences with self-awareness practice. Genetic counseling students had significantly lower mean scores on the MAAS and the Insight subscale of the SRIS compared with other health professionals, indicating that genetic counseling students have lower levels of mindfulness and may lack insight into their thoughts and feelings. After starting genetic counseling graduate programs, students were more likely to reduce participation in active self-awareness practices such as physical activity and mental health counseling. Most students reported having structured practice in self-care (n = 97, 63%), reflection (n = 125, 81.2%), and mindfulness (n = 77, 50%) as a part of their training programs. Second-year genetic counseling students reporting mindfulness practices had significantly higher scores on the Insight subscale of the SRIS than those who did not, indicating that students engaged in mindfulness practice are better able to understand their thoughts, feelings, and behavior. The majority of students reported benefitting from structured practice in self-care (n = 63, 64.9%), reflection (n = 101, 80%), and mindfulness (n = 54, 70.1%). Open-ended responses regarding students' perceived benefits and limitations of structured practice were analyzed for recurrent themes. Students reported improved self-awareness which enhanced their counseling relationships during clinical rotations. However, they also perceived that implementation of self-awareness practices may have been inconsistent. Findings from this study have implications for integrating self-awareness practices into genetic counseling graduate curriculum.
压力和焦虑是从事遗传咨询的专业人员以及遗传咨询学生的重要关注点,并且会对患者护理产生下游影响。先前的研究表明,在自我意识实践方面进行研究生水平的培训,例如自我保健、反思和正念,可能会对遗传咨询师、他们的患者以及整个专业产生持久的影响。这项混合方法研究使用自我反思与洞察量表(SRIS)、正念注意意识量表(MAAS)以及自我描述的自我意识实践经验,评估了 154 名遗传咨询研究生的自我意识。与其他健康专业人员相比,遗传咨询学生的 MAAS 和 SRIS 的洞察子量表的平均得分明显较低,这表明遗传咨询学生的正念水平较低,并且可能缺乏对自己的思想和感受的洞察力。在开始遗传咨询研究生课程后,学生更有可能减少参加身体活动和心理健康咨询等主动自我意识实践的活动。大多数学生报告在自我保健(n=97,63%)、反思(n=125,81.2%)和正念(n=77,50%)方面有结构化的实践,作为他们培训计划的一部分。报告有正念实践的第二年遗传咨询学生在 SRIS 的洞察子量表上的得分明显高于没有报告的学生,这表明参与正念实践的学生能够更好地理解自己的想法、感受和行为。大多数学生报告从结构化的自我保健实践(n=63,64.9%)、反思(n=101,80%)和正念(n=54,70.1%)中受益。对学生关于结构化实践的感知益处和局限性的开放式回答进行了反复出现的主题的分析。学生报告说,自我意识的提高增强了他们在临床轮转中的咨询关系。然而,他们也认为自我意识实践的实施可能不一致。这项研究的结果对将自我意识实践纳入遗传咨询研究生课程具有重要意义。