Bulmer Laura, Stanley Christy, Knauth Lauren Loffredo, Doyle Lauren E, Mills Rachel
MS Genetic Counseling Program, The University of North Carolina at Greensboro, Greensboro, North Carolina, USA.
Department of Women's Health, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina, USA.
J Genet Couns. 2023 Dec;32(6):1144-1153. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1764. Epub 2023 Aug 14.
Genetic counseling graduate programs provide a rigorous curriculum comprised of coursework encompassing counseling and medical genetics, fieldwork, and research experience. Students face similar emotional and mental demands as practicing genetic counselors while also experiencing stressors commonly associated with graduate study. Increased self-awareness may help combat these stressors. This mixed-methods study surveyed 154 genetic counseling graduate students to determine the types of self-awareness practices they would like to have included in their graduate training and surveyed 11 program faculty regarding the feasibility of implementing these practices. The students' most preferred practices were self-reflection (n = 73, 47.4%), support from peers, colleagues, and/or supervisors (n = 71, 46.1%), and mental health counseling (n = 71, 46.1%). Analysis of responses to open-ended questions capturing students' recommendations for programs yielded six recurrent themes: (1) Consistent, Structured Practice with Accountability, (2) Emphasis on Mental Health, (3) Practical Techniques, (4) Access to Resources, (5) Encouragement and Support, and (6) Barriers to Implementation. Many students suggested that programs should incorporate repetitive exercises that could be implemented on a schedule with an emphasis on consistency (Theme 1). Students also emphasized the importance of providing exposure to multiple examples of self-awareness practices, so they could find an approach that was most beneficial on an individual basis (Theme 3). These findings were shared with program faculty via a presentation at the Association for Genetic Counseling Program Directors annual meeting, and attendees were subsequently surveyed regarding self-awareness practices currently integrated into their curriculum, as well as the feasibility and likelihood of integrating new practices. Program faculty respondents indicated that most of the recommended practices were included in their curriculum already or would be feasible and likely to incorporate. These results provide insight into the attitudes of genetic counseling students toward structured practice in self-awareness and how genetic counseling graduate programs might integrate such practices into the curriculum.
遗传咨询研究生项目提供了一门严谨的课程,包括涵盖咨询和医学遗传学的课程作业、实地考察和研究经验。学生面临着与执业遗传咨询师相似的情感和心理需求,同时也经历着与研究生学习相关的常见压力源。增强自我意识可能有助于应对这些压力源。这项混合方法研究调查了154名遗传咨询研究生,以确定他们希望在研究生培训中纳入的自我意识实践类型,并就实施这些实践的可行性调查了11名项目教员。学生最喜欢的实践是自我反思(n = 73,47.4%)、来自同伴、同事和/或 supervisor 的支持(n = 71,46.1%)以及心理健康咨询(n = 71,46.1%)。对收集学生对项目建议的开放式问题的回答进行分析,得出了六个反复出现的主题:(1)有问责制的一致、结构化实践,(2)对心理健康的强调,(3)实用技巧,(4)资源获取,(5)鼓励和支持,以及(6)实施障碍。许多学生建议项目应纳入可按计划实施的重复性练习,并强调一致性(主题1)。学生们还强调了提供多种自我意识实践示例的重要性,这样他们就可以找到对个人最有益的方法(主题3)。这些研究结果通过在遗传咨询项目主任协会年会上的报告与项目教员分享,随后对与会者进行了调查,了解他们目前课程中纳入的自我意识实践,以及纳入新实践的可行性和可能性。项目教员受访者表示,大多数推荐的实践已经包含在他们的课程中,或者是可行的且可能会纳入。这些结果为遗传咨询学生对自我意识结构化实践的态度以及遗传咨询研究生项目如何将此类实践纳入课程提供了见解。