Hanke Laura Isabel, Wachter Nicolas, Boedecker Christian, Penzkofer Lea, Koch Martina, Dietz Sven-Oliver, König Tatjana Tamara, Heinemann Markus K, Neulen Axel, Kurz Sandra, Lang Hauke, Huber Tobias
Klinik für Allgemein-, Viszeral- und Transplantationschirurgie, Universitätsmedizin der Johannes Gutenberg-Universität, Mainz, Deutschland.
Zentrum für Orthopädie und Unfallchirurgie, Universitätsmedizin der Johannes Gutenberg-Universität, Mainz, Deutschland.
Zentralbl Chir. 2021 Dec;146(6):586-596. doi: 10.1055/a-1675-3955. Epub 2021 Dec 6.
Education of medical students in surgery not only consists of knowledge about diseases and their treatment but also of practical skills like i.e. suturing. In the clinical training of medical students, professional interaction and communication with patients is a key component. Due to the circumstances of distancing and reduced exposure to patients during the COVID-19 pandemic, clinical training of medical students has been challenging. To combat these restrictions, digital modern teaching concepts had to be implemented.
Surgical education of medical students was reorganised during the summer semester 2020 and winter semester 2020/2021 and the necessary adjustments, as well as their evaluation by students, were analysed. Results were compared to the pre-COVID evaluations of the summer semester 2019. Furthermore a survey of all university surgical departments in Germany (n = 39) was conducted to compare the different approaches to handling this very new situation.
All participating centres were performing surgical education with medical students during the COVID-19 pandemic. Overall, digital teaching methods were well accepted by students and teachers, even though short-term changes were necessary during the second wave of the pandemic. Both students and teachers missed the direct mutual interaction as well as with patients (summer semester 2020 36%, winter semester 2020/2021 40%). Modern and digital teaching concepts were assessed positively (summer semester 2020 45%, winter semester 2020/2021 40%) and long term implementation was desired by students and teachers (winter semester 2020/2021 60%).
Training of practical surgical skills, as well as communication skills, can only be taught in presence. Digital learning concepts can support, but not replace, surgical courses held in presence, including contact to patients and manual training. Blended learning concepts facilitate a leap towards modern teaching concepts and increase the quality of classes spent in presence.
医学生的外科教育不仅包括疾病及其治疗方面的知识,还包括诸如缝合等实践技能。在医学生的临床培训中,与患者的专业互动和沟通是一个关键组成部分。由于在新冠疫情期间需要保持社交距离并减少与患者的接触,医学生的临床培训面临挑战。为应对这些限制,必须实施数字化现代教学理念。
在2020年夏季学期和2020/2021年冬季学期对医学生的外科教育进行了重组,并分析了必要的调整以及学生对这些调整的评价。将结果与2019年夏季学期新冠疫情前的评价进行了比较。此外,对德国所有大学外科科室(n = 39)进行了一项调查,以比较处理这一全新情况的不同方法。
在新冠疫情期间,所有参与中心都在对医学生进行外科教育。总体而言,数字化教学方法受到学生和教师的广泛接受,尽管在疫情第二波期间有必要进行短期调整。学生和教师都怀念直接的相互互动以及与患者的互动(2020年夏季学期为36%,2020/2021年冬季学期为40%)。现代和数字化教学理念得到了积极评价(2020年夏季学期为45%,2020/2021年冬季学期为40%),学生和教师希望长期实施(2020/2021年冬季学期为60%)。
实践外科技能以及沟通技能的培训只能在面对面的情况下进行。数字化学习理念可以提供支持,但不能取代面对面的外科课程,包括与患者的接触和实践培训。混合式学习理念有助于向现代教学理念迈进,并提高面对面课程的质量。