Lamberti Anna Gabriella, Ujfalusi Zoltan, Told Roland, Hanna Dániel, Józsa Gergő, Maróti Péter
Medical Centre, Department of Paediatrics, Division of Paediatric Surgery, Traumatology, Urology, and Paediatric Otolaryngology, UP Clinical Centre, 7 Jozsef Attila Str., HU-7623 Pecs, Hungary.
Department of Thermophysiology, Institute for Translational Medicine, Medical School, University of Pecs, 12 Szigeti Str., HU-7624 Pecs, Hungary.
Polymers (Basel). 2021 Nov 29;13(23):4179. doi: 10.3390/polym13234179.
Additive manufacturing technologies are essential in biomedical modeling and prototyping. Polymer-based bone models are widely used in simulating surgical interventions and procedures. Distal forearm fractures are the most common pediatric fractures, in which the Kirschner wire fixation is the most widely used operative method. However, there is still lingering controversy throughout the published literature regarding the number of wires and sites of insertion. This study aims to critically compare the biomechanical stability of different K-wire fixation techniques. Different osteosyntheses were reconstructed on 189 novel standardized bone models, which were created using 3D printing and molding techniques, using PLA and polyurethane materials, and it has been characterized in terms of mechanical behavior and structure. X-ray imaging has also been performed. The validation of the model was successful: the relative standard deviations (RSD = 100 × SD × mean, where RSD is relative standard deviation, SD is the standard deviation) of the mechanical parameters varied between 1.1% (10° torsion; 6.52 Nm ± 0.07 Nm) and 5.3% (5° torsion; 4.33 Nm ± 0.23 Nm). The simulated fractures were fixed using two K-wires inserted from radial and dorsal directions (crossed wire fixation) or both from the radial direction, in parallel (parallel wire fixation). Single-wire fixations with shifted exit points were also included. Additionally, three-point bending tests with dorsal and radial load and torsion tests were performed. We measured the maximum force required for a 5 mm displacement of the probe under dorsal and radial loads (means for crossed wire fixation: 249.5 N and 355.9 N; parallel wire fixation: 246.4 N and 308.3 N; single wire fixation: 115.9 N and 166.5 N). We also measured the torque required for 5° and 10° torsion (which varied between 0.15 Nm for 5° and 0.36 Nm for 10° torsion). The crossed wire fixation provided the most stability during the three-point bending tests. Against torsion, both the crossed and parallel wire fixation were superior to the single-wire fixations. The 3D printed model is found to be a reliable, cost-effective tool that can be used to characterize the different fixation methods, and it can be used in further pre-clinical investigations.
增材制造技术在生物医学建模和原型制作中至关重要。基于聚合物的骨模型广泛应用于模拟手术干预和操作。前臂远端骨折是最常见的小儿骨折,其中克氏针固定是最常用的手术方法。然而,在已发表的文献中,关于克氏针数量和插入部位仍存在争议。本研究旨在严格比较不同克氏针固定技术的生物力学稳定性。在189个新型标准化骨模型上重建了不同的骨合成,这些模型是使用3D打印和成型技术,采用聚乳酸(PLA)和聚氨酯材料制作的,并对其力学行为和结构进行了表征。还进行了X射线成像。模型验证成功:力学参数的相对标准偏差(RSD = 100×SD÷均值,其中RSD是相对标准偏差,SD是标准偏差)在1.1%(10°扭转;6.52 N·m±0.07 N·m)至5.3%(5°扭转;4.33 N·m±0.23 N·m)之间变化。模拟骨折采用从桡侧和背侧方向插入两根克氏针(交叉克氏针固定)或均从桡侧方向平行插入(平行克氏针固定)进行固定。还包括出口点偏移的单针固定。此外,进行了背侧和桡侧加载的三点弯曲试验以及扭转试验。我们测量了在背侧和桡侧加载下探头位移5 mm所需的最大力(交叉克氏针固定的均值:249.5 N和355.9 N;平行克氏针固定:246.4 N和308.3 N;单针固定:115.9 N和166.5 N)。我们还测量了5°和10°扭转所需的扭矩(5°扭转时在0.15 N·m至10°扭转时在0.36 N·m之间变化)。在三点弯曲试验中,交叉克氏针固定提供了最大的稳定性。在抗扭转方面,交叉和平行克氏针固定均优于单针固定。发现3D打印模型是一种可靠、经济高效的工具,可用于表征不同的固定方法,并可用于进一步的临床前研究。