Tommy's Stillbirth Research Centre, School of Medical Sciences, Division of Developmental Biology and Medicine, Faculty of Biology, Medicine, and Health, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
HRB-Trials Methodology Research Network, School of Nursing and Midwifery, National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland.
Trials. 2021 Dec 9;22(1):894. doi: 10.1186/s13063-021-05839-9.
Concerns regarding reduced fetal movements (RFM) are reported in 5-15% of pregnancies, and RFM are associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes including fetal growth restriction and stillbirth. Studies have aimed to improve pregnancy outcomes by evaluating interventions to raise awareness of RFM in pregnancy, such as kick counting, evaluating interventions for the clinical management of RFM, or both. However, there is not currently a core outcome set (COS) for studies of RFM. This study aims to create a COS for use in research studies that aim to raise awareness of RFM and/or evaluate interventions for the clinical management of RFM.
A systematic review will be conducted, to identify outcomes used in randomised and non-randomised studies with control groups that aimed to raise awareness of RFM (for example by using mindfulness techniques, fetal movement counting, or other tools such as leaflets or mobile phone applications) and/or that evaluated the clinical management of RFM. An international Delphi consensus will then be used whereby stakeholders will rate the importance of the outcomes identified in the systematic review in (i) awareness and (ii) clinical management studies. The preliminary lists of outcomes will be discussed at a consensus meeting where one final COS for awareness and management, or two discrete COS (one for awareness and one for management), will be agreed upon.
A well-developed COS will provide researchers with the minimum set of outcomes that should be measured and reported in studies that aim to quantify the effects of interventions.
在 5-15%的妊娠中会报告胎儿运动减少(RFM)的担忧,并且 RFM 与不良妊娠结局相关,包括胎儿生长受限和死产。为了改善妊娠结局,研究旨在通过评估提高妊娠中 RFM 意识的干预措施,例如踢打计数,评估 RFM 临床管理的干预措施,或两者兼而有之。然而,目前针对 RFM 的研究尚无核心结局集(COS)。本研究旨在为旨在提高 RFM 意识和/或评估 RFM 临床管理干预措施的研究创建一个 COS。
将进行系统评价,以确定具有对照组的随机和非随机研究中使用的结局,这些研究旨在提高 RFM 意识(例如通过使用正念技术、胎儿运动计数或其他工具,如传单或移动应用程序)和/或评估 RFM 的临床管理。然后将使用国际 Delphi 共识,让利益相关者对系统评价中确定的结局在(i)意识和(ii)临床管理研究中的重要性进行评分。初步的结局清单将在共识会议上进行讨论,会上将商定最终的意识和管理 COS,或两个独立的 COS(一个用于意识,一个用于管理)。
一个完善的 COS 将为研究人员提供应在旨在量化干预效果的研究中测量和报告的最小结局集。