Sociology Department, Goldsmiths, University of London, London, UK.
Br J Sociol. 2022 Jan;73(1):206-219. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.12918. Epub 2021 Dec 24.
This article counters the view (albeit contested) of race as a natural empirical object with technology as a secondary, external entity applied to it. Instead, I posit race itself as a technology that is inherently discriminatory in motivation, design and function, as evident throughout its brutally effective history. Focusing on the post/genomic era, I consider contemporary forms of molecular racialization as the latest technological iteration of race as a disciplinary device. I characterize this biopolitical racial technology as operant through a carceral methodology in four stages: (a) the epistemological mutability of molecular racialization as reiterating the obscurantist claim of modern raciology to constitute a benign description of literal racial difference; (b) the ontological de-individualization of certain racial others as aggregated risky populations and legitimate targets of repressive management; (c) a predictive empiricism whereby molecular race is seen as indicative of potential behaviours that sanctions oppressive state interventions against specific populations; (d) a normative bioethical dissembling whereby state agencies' exploitation of target molecular racialized populations' vulnerabilities result in the debarment of proper ethical consideration and the right to justice. Drawing largely on criminal justice and immigration control examples, the article asserts that the carceral methodologies of molecular racialization demonstrate race as a repressive technology designed to (re)produce subaltern racial populations and propagate racism.
本文反驳了将种族视为自然经验对象,而将技术视为应用于其上的次要外部实体的观点(尽管存在争议)。相反,我假设种族本身就是一种技术,其动机、设计和功能本质上是歧视性的,这在其残酷有效的历史中显而易见。本文聚焦于后/基因组时代,将当代形式的分子种族化视为作为一种纪律手段的种族的最新技术迭代。我将这种生物政治种族技术描述为通过以下四个阶段的监禁方法发挥作用:(a)分子种族化的认识论可变性,因为它重复了现代种族学的模糊主张,即构成对字面种族差异的良性描述;(b)某些种族他者的本体论去个体化,因为他们被视为聚集的危险人群和有针对性的镇压管理的合法目标;(c)一种预测性经验主义,即分子种族被视为可能行为的指示,这些行为允许对特定人群进行压迫性的国家干预;(d)一种规范的生物伦理掩饰,即国家机构利用目标分子种族化人群的脆弱性,导致对适当伦理考虑和正义权利的剥夺。本文主要以刑事司法和移民管制为例,断言分子种族化的监禁方法表明种族是一种压迫性技术,旨在(重新)产生从属的种族群体,并传播种族主义。