University of South Carolina, Columbia.
University of South Carolina, Columbia.
J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2022 Aug;61(8):1034-1040. doi: 10.1016/j.jaac.2021.11.029. Epub 2021 Dec 21.
Educational environments that are structured by race perpetuate poor mental health for Black adolescents. This empirical relationship is pronounced when it is examined through Racial Battle Fatigue theory, which provides a framework that links educational environments and poor psychological health of Black students. School police have a major effect on Black adolescents' educational and health experiences and trajectories. The purpose of this person-centered study was to assess the risk of Black students' depressive symptoms who were stopped by school police, saw other students stopped by school police, or experienced school discipline.
Data on Black student youths from the Fragile Families Study Year 15 wave (N = 1,601) were used to conduct a latent class analysis to identify subgroups of school policing (ie, being stopped by school police, seeing other students stopped by school police) and school discipline on the distal outcome of depressive symptoms. Covariates included demographic and school attachment.
We identified 4 distinct Black student subgroups: (1) unscathed [no school policing or discipline reported]; (2) school disciplined; (3) combined school policing; and (4) school policed [arrested by police]. Each subgroup had an incremental increase in mean depressive symptom scores. Compared to the unscathed subgroup, each subgroup also had lower school attachment.
This study disrupts the notion that education environments are a social determinant of health and a great equalizer. This study critically exposes how educational institutions complicit with school policing are associated with racism-related mental health conditions of Black youths.
种族结构化的教育环境会对黑人青少年的心理健康造成持久的不良影响。通过种族战斗疲劳理论来检验这种实证关系时,这种关系更为明显,该理论为教育环境与黑人学生心理健康状况不佳之间的联系提供了一个框架。学校警察对黑人青少年的教育和健康体验和轨迹有重大影响。本以人为中心的研究旨在评估被学校警察拦下、看到其他学生被学校警察拦下或经历学校纪律处分的黑人学生出现抑郁症状的风险。
使用来自脆弱家庭研究第 15 波(N=1601)的黑人学生青年的数据,进行潜在类别分析,以确定学校警察(即被学校警察拦下、看到其他学生被学校警察拦下)和学校纪律处分对抑郁症状这一远端结果的亚组。协变量包括人口统计学和学校依恋。
我们确定了 4 个不同的黑人学生亚组:(1)未受影响[未报告学校警察或纪律处分];(2)学校纪律处分;(3)综合学校警察;(4)学校警察[被警察逮捕]。每个亚组的平均抑郁症状评分都有递增。与未受影响的亚组相比,每个亚组的学校依恋程度也较低。
这项研究打破了教育环境是健康的社会决定因素和巨大平衡器的观念。这项研究批判性地揭示了教育机构与学校警察勾结如何与黑人青年的与种族有关的心理健康状况有关。