Queiroz Rejane Christine de Sousa, Oliveira Izabel Cristina Vieira de, Silva Núbia Cristina da, Borges Tassia Silvana, Nunes Ana Margarida Melo, Figueiredo Nilcema, Thomaz Erika Barbara Abreu Fonseca
Department of Public Health, Federal University of Maranhão, São Luís, Brazil.
Post Graduate Program in Dentistry, Federal University of Maranhão, São Luís, Brazil.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2022 Feb;50(1):48-57. doi: 10.1111/cdoe.12719.
To identify changes in the dental service provision to people with disabilities (PD) in the Dental Specialties Centers (acronym CEO in Portuguese-Centro de Especialidades Odontológicas) between the first and second cycles of the Program for the Improvement of Access and Quality of CEO and analyse factors associated with any changes.
This nationwide ecological time series study adopted the CEO as the analysis unit. The 827 CEO who participated in the two program's cycles (2014 and 2018) were included. Data on the structure and the work process were considered to identify features of providing services to PD in both cycles. Latent transition analysis (LTA) was performed to identify latent status (LS) with similar features and model the transition between LS over time. Models with five variables and with two to five LS were tested, considered best conceptual interpretability and best model fit parameters: human resources structure (dentist working exclusively with PD) and work process that identified guarantee of PD treatment at the CEO, the CEO's interface with primary care, and the interface with tertiary care. Spatial analysis was performed to identify spatial patterns of LS in the Brazilian territory with choropleth maps. A multinomial logistic regression model was performed to identify factors associated with changes in the provision of CEO (improved, remained or worsened).
The best-fit model identified four LS: 'Better', 'Medium better', 'Medium worse' and 'Worse'. CEO remained in the LS 'Better' (94%), LS 'Medium' (5.3%) and LS 'Worse' (78.4%). It is noteworthy that the highest proportion of CEO, in both cycles, was in the LS 'Better', featured by the CEO, characterized by all the CEO guaranteeing treatment to users with PD, high proportions of professionals working exclusively with PD, and most CEO articulated with primary care and with tertiary care. However, there is a decrease in the number of postgraduate professionals specializing in this service profile (1.3%). The higher the population growth, the greater the likelihood of the CEO achieving 'improved' in the LS. Moreover, the higher the number of goals, the lower the likelihood of the CEO getting 'worse' in the LS.
Advances in dental service provision were observed, with more significant transitions to the 'Better' class, with improvements mainly in the interface with primary and tertiary care. Disability will be an even more significant concern as the population ages. Initiatives that can remove barriers and empower PD are potent in the provision of oral health services.
确定在口腔专科中心(葡萄牙语简称为CEO - Centro de Especialidades Odontológicas),针对残疾人提供的牙科服务在CEO改善服务可及性与质量计划的第一个周期和第二个周期之间的变化,并分析与这些变化相关的因素。
这项全国性的生态时间序列研究采用CEO作为分析单位。纳入了参与该计划两个周期(2014年和2018年)的827个CEO。考虑了有关结构和工作流程的数据,以确定两个周期中为残疾人提供服务的特征。进行了潜在转变分析(LTA),以识别具有相似特征的潜在状态(LS),并对LS随时间的转变进行建模。测试了包含五个变量以及具有两到五个LS的模型,认为这些模型具有最佳的概念可解释性和最佳的模型拟合参数:人力资源结构(专门为残疾人工作的牙医)以及确定在CEO处为残疾人提供治疗保障、CEO与初级保健的接口以及与三级保健的接口的工作流程。进行了空间分析,以通过等值线图识别巴西境内LS的空间模式。进行了多项逻辑回归模型分析,以确定与CEO服务提供变化(改善、维持或恶化)相关的因素。
最佳拟合模型确定了四个LS:“更好”、“中等更好”、“中等更差”和“更差”。CEO保持在“更好”的LS(94%)、“中等”的LS(5.3%)和“更差”的LS(78.4%)。值得注意的是,在两个周期中,处于“更好”LS的CEO比例最高,其特征是所有CEO都为残疾用户提供治疗保障,专门为残疾人工作的专业人员比例较高,并且大多数CEO与初级保健和三级保健都有联系。然而,专门从事该服务领域的研究生专业人员数量有所减少(1.3%)。人口增长越高,CEO在LS中实现“改善”的可能性就越大。此外,目标数量越高,CEO在LS中变得“更差”的可能性就越低。
观察到牙科服务提供方面的进展,向“更好”类别有更显著的转变,主要在与初级和三级保健的接口方面有所改善。随着人口老龄化,残疾问题将成为更重大的关注点。能够消除障碍并增强残疾人能力的举措在提供口腔健康服务方面很有效。