Department of Psychology and Neuroscience, Duke University.
Department of English (Linguistics Program), North Carolina State University.
Cogn Sci. 2021 Jan;46(1):e13075. doi: 10.1111/cogs.13075.
Words sound slightly different each time they are said, both by the same talker and across talkers. Rather than hurting learning, lab studies suggest that talker variability helps infants learn similar sounding words. However, very little is known about how much variability infants hear within a single talker or across talkers in naturalistic input. Here, we quantified these types of talker variability for highly frequent words spoken to 44 infants, from naturalistic recordings sampled longitudinally over a year of life (from 6 to 17 months). We used non-contrastive acoustic measurements (e.g., mean pitch, duration, harmonics-to-noise ratio) and holistic measures of sound similarity (normalized acoustic distance) to quantify acoustic variability. We find three key results. First, pitch-based variability was generally lower for infants' top talkers than across their other talkers, but overall acoustic distance is higher for tokens from the top talker versus the others. Second, the amount of acoustic variability infants heard could not be predicted from, and thus was not redundant with, other properties of the input such as the number of talkers or tokens, or proportion of speech from particular sources (e.g., women, children, electronics). Finally, we find that patterns of pitch-based acoustic variability heard in naturalistic input were similar to those found with in-lab stimuli that facilitated word learning. This large-scale quantification of talker variability in infants' everyday input sets the stage for linking naturally occurring variability "in the wild" to early word learning.
每次说话时,同一个说话者和不同说话者说出的单词听起来都略有不同。实验室研究表明,说话者的变化有助于婴儿学习相似发音的单词,而不是对学习造成伤害。然而,对于婴儿在自然输入中从单个说话者或不同说话者那里听到的变化量知之甚少。在这里,我们对从自然记录中提取的、44 名婴儿一年内的纵向样本(6 至 17 个月)中高频单词的这些类型的说话者变化进行了量化。我们使用非对比性声学测量(例如,平均音高、持续时间、谐波噪声比)和声音相似性的整体测量(归一化声学距离)来量化声学变化。我们发现了三个关键结果。首先,对于婴儿的主要说话者,基于音高的变化通常比其他说话者的变化要低,但来自主要说话者的音位与其他说话者相比,整体声学距离更高。其次,婴儿听到的声学变化量无法从输入的其他特性(例如说话者数量或音位数量,或特定来源(如女性、儿童、电子设备)的语音比例)中预测到,因此不是冗余的。最后,我们发现,在自然输入中听到的基于音高的声学变化模式与那些在促进单词学习的实验室刺激中发现的模式相似。对婴儿日常输入中说话者变化的这种大规模量化为将自然发生的“野外”变化与早期单词学习联系起来奠定了基础。