Sousa Amandia, Herkrath Fernando J, Wallace Carolyn, Farmer Jane, Bousquat Aylene
Institute Leônidas e Maria Deane, Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (Fiocruz), Rua Terezina, 476 - Adrianópolis, Manaus, Amazonas 69058278, Brazil; and Politics, Management and Health Department, University of São Paulo, São Paulo 01246904, Brazil
Institute Leônidas e Maria Deane, Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (Fiocruz), Rua Terezina, 476 - Adrianópolis, Manaus, Amazonas 69058278, Brazil
Rural Remote Health. 2022 Jan;22(1):6747. doi: 10.22605/RRH6747. Epub 2022 Jan 1.
Health studies of the Amazon often focus on diseases and infections prevalent in the region, and few studies address health organizations and services. In this sense, this study fills a gap by reviewing the studies aimed at primary healthcare (PHC) implementation in the nine Amazonian countries. This review addresses a need to explore the forms in which PHC is implemented in the Amazon areas outside the urban centers and its potential to reduce health inequities. This study contributes to improvements in the practices of managers and health professionals and research on the topic.
Scoping review methodology was applied to peer-reviewed articles. The databases searched were PubMed, Scopus, Lilacs, Embase and Web of Science. Selected studies included peer-reviewed publications, published between January 2000 and November 2019, that focused on PHC or one of its components in the Amazon, and were published in English, Spanish and Portuguese. The study used Arksey and O'Malley's scoping review guidelines, supported by Levac, and included five steps: (i) identification phase, where search queries were applied to the databases followed by the removal of duplicates; (ii) screening phase, where titles and abstracts of articles were screened to exclude irrelevant articles; (iii) eligibility phase, where the full texts of articles were read to assess their relevancy to this study; (iv) data extraction, using a spreadsheet designed to capture relevant information required in this review, using an iterative process; (v) summarizing and classification of each article according to content. The second and third phases were conducted independently by two reviewers. If a disagreement arose between the reviewers, a third reviewer was consulted to help decide whether to include or exclude a study.
This review included 25 studies. Of these, 11 presented promising results regarding PHC functioning in the Amazon region, and 14 presented challenges and difficulties in its functioning. Some PHC strategies implemented in the Amazon showed the potential to reduce inequities, mostly when they involved actions that increased access to PHC in the region when they developed a culturally adapted role and engaged community members in the decision-making and in the collaborative construction of health services. Actions that exposed challenges and difficulties were related to ill-prepared healthcare professionals, inadequate service approach and the inability to adapt to cultural issues.
The findings reveal information about PHC implementations that have had promising results in the Amazon region and, at the same time, show the challenges and difficulties of the PHC actions. The findings also highlight and synthesize knowledge about the potential that PHC strategies have to affect existing inequities in the Amazon region and gaps in the studies that have been undertaken, or at least published, including a lack of studies of PHC implementation and examination of strategies aimed at health determinants.
对亚马逊地区的健康研究通常聚焦于该地区流行的疾病和感染,很少有研究涉及卫生组织和服务。从这个意义上说,本研究通过回顾针对亚马逊地区九个国家初级卫生保健(PHC)实施情况的研究填补了一项空白。这项综述满足了探索初级卫生保健在城市中心以外的亚马逊地区的实施形式及其减少健康不平等的潜力的需求。本研究有助于改进管理人员和卫生专业人员的实践以及该主题的研究。
对同行评审的文章应用了范围综述方法。检索的数据库有PubMed、Scopus、Lilacs、Embase和Web of Science。选定的研究包括2000年1月至2019年11月期间发表的、聚焦于亚马逊地区初级卫生保健或其组成部分之一、且以英文、西班牙文和葡萄牙文发表的同行评审出版物。该研究采用了由Levac支持的Arksey和O'Malley的范围综述指南,包括五个步骤:(i)识别阶段,将检索查询应用于数据库,然后去除重复项;(ii)筛选阶段,筛选文章的标题和摘要以排除不相关的文章;(iii)资格阶段,阅读文章全文以评估其与本研究的相关性;(iv)数据提取,使用一个设计用于捕获本综述所需相关信息的电子表格,采用迭代过程;(v)根据内容对每篇文章进行总结和分类。第二和第三阶段由两名评审员独立进行。如果评审员之间出现分歧,则咨询第三名评审员以帮助决定是否纳入或排除一项研究。
本综述纳入了25项研究。其中,11项研究呈现了关于亚马逊地区初级卫生保健运作的有前景的结果,14项研究呈现了其运作中的挑战和困难。在亚马逊地区实施的一些初级卫生保健策略显示出减少不平等的潜力,主要是当这些策略涉及增加该地区初级卫生保健可及性的行动、发挥适应文化的作用以及让社区成员参与决策和卫生服务的协同建设时。暴露挑战和困难的行动与准备不足的卫生专业人员、不充分的服务方式以及无法适应文化问题有关。
研究结果揭示了在亚马逊地区取得有前景结果的初级卫生保健实施情况的信息,同时也显示了初级卫生保健行动的挑战和困难。研究结果还突出并综合了关于初级卫生保健策略影响亚马逊地区现有不平等的潜力以及已开展或至少已发表的研究中的差距的知识,包括缺乏对初级卫生保健实施的研究以及对旨在解决健康决定因素的策略的审视。