Pandey Ritesh Arvind, Johari Ashok N
Department of Orthopaedics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Phulwari Sharif, Aurangabad Road, Patna, Bihar 801507 India.
Children's Orthopaedic Centre, 2nd Floor, Bobby Apartments, 143 L.J. Road, Mahim (West), Mumbai, 400016 India.
Indian J Orthop. 2021 May 2;55(6):1388-1401. doi: 10.1007/s43465-021-00409-2. eCollection 2021 Dec.
Developmental dysplasia of hip (DDH) is a common disorder of childhood and has a good prognosis when treated at an early age. In spite of being a significant concern, many children with DDH are not picked early and present late at walking age. In our country, it is presumed to be due to absence of a national policy for screening of DDH. Screening programmes including the combination of clinical and radiological methods in different ways have been suggested. However, the exact method of screening is controversial.
To analyze effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of various screening methods for DDH.
Systematic review.
This review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines. Medline database was explored for original case series and randomized clinical trials. Inclusion criteria were English language, screening for DDH in neonates, sample size more than 500, and studies with minimum duration of one year.
Thirty-four studies were selected to write the manuscript. This included 23 studies looking for effectiveness of a screening programme and 11 studies comparing various outcomes of different screening strategies. A trend favoring universal ultrasound screening was observed.
The literature supports universal ultrasound screening and has proved its cost-effectiveness. However, considering the logistic and financial challenges in our country, immediate implementation of universal ultrasound screening seems impractical. In the absence of any current guidelines for screening for DDH in India, we suggest professional organizations involved in the care of children and public health policy-makers to come together to develop national screening guidelines for DDH.
发育性髋关节发育不良(DDH)是儿童期常见疾病,早期治疗预后良好。尽管这是一个重大问题,但许多DDH患儿未被早期发现,在学步期才被诊断出来。在我国,推测是由于缺乏DDH筛查的国家政策。已经提出了不同方式结合临床和放射学方法的筛查方案。然而,确切的筛查方法存在争议。
分析DDH各种筛查方法的有效性和成本效益。
系统评价。
本评价按照PRISMA指南进行。在Medline数据库中检索原始病例系列和随机临床试验。纳入标准为英文文献、新生儿DDH筛查、样本量超过500以及研究持续时间至少一年。
选择了34项研究撰写本手稿。其中包括23项评估筛查方案有效性的研究和11项比较不同筛查策略各种结果的研究。观察到普遍超声筛查更具优势的趋势。
文献支持普遍超声筛查,并证明了其成本效益。然而,考虑到我国在后勤和财政方面的挑战,立即实施普遍超声筛查似乎不切实际。在印度目前没有DDH筛查指南的情况下,我们建议参与儿童护理的专业组织和公共卫生政策制定者共同制定DDH的国家筛查指南。