Academic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Group, Barts and the London School of Medicine and Dentistry, Queen Mary University of London.
Department of Surgery, Queen's Hospital, Romford.
J Craniofac Surg. 2022;33(5):1331-1334. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000008420. Epub 2022 Jan 10.
There is a significant unmet need for cleft repair in low-income countries. The procedure is challenging due to limited access, small fragile flaps, and the depth at which sutures need to be placed. The aim of this analysis is to review available literature pertaining to cleft lip and palate repair training, with a focus on those applicable to low-income countries.
Literature searches of Medline and EMBase were performed to identify studies of cleft lip and/or palate training. Terms including "cleft," "lip," "palate," and "training" were searched. Literature published in English from inception to May 2021 in which the full text was available was considered for inclusion. Studies were included on the basis that they included interventions such as virtual/online training, simulation training, courses, fellowships, and/or hospital-based training. Studies that met this criterion were further assessed using a validated scoring tool then the applicability of each training strategy for low-income countries reviewed.
Nineteen studies were included in this analysis. Of these 4 studies pertained to online training, 11 studies illustrated cleft models and simulation training, while 4 studies highlighted the role of charity led training achieved through direct hospital teaching and fellowship programs. The training strategies described have been summarised and presented herein in a narrative format. The simplicity, fidelity, and training benefit of palatoplasty models has also been described.
Cleft lip and palate repair training should be accessible to surgeons in low-income countries. Direct practical experience has an important role in training to perform cleft procedures. Affordable, simple simulation models that resemble human tissue are essential so that surgeons can safely practice skills between initial training and operating on a living child.
在低收入国家,唇腭裂修复的需求未得到满足。由于可及性有限、脆弱的小皮瓣以及需要缝合的深度,该手术具有挑战性。本分析旨在回顾有关唇腭裂修复培训的现有文献,重点是适用于低收入国家的文献。
对 Medline 和 EMBase 进行文献检索,以确定唇腭裂培训的研究。搜索的术语包括“cleft”、“lip”、“palate”和“training”。考虑纳入英语发表的文献,从成立到 2021 年 5 月,全文可用。研究的纳入标准是它们包括虚拟/在线培训、模拟培训、课程、奖学金和/或基于医院的培训等干预措施。符合这一标准的研究进一步使用经过验证的评分工具进行评估,然后评估每种培训策略在低收入国家的适用性。
本分析纳入了 19 项研究。其中 4 项研究涉及在线培训,11 项研究说明了腭裂模型和模拟培训,4 项研究强调了通过直接医院教学和奖学金计划开展慈善主导培训的作用。在此以叙述性格式总结并呈现了所描述的培训策略。本文还描述了腭裂模型的简单性、保真度和培训效益。
唇腭裂修复培训应在低收入国家的外科医生中普及。直接实践经验在进行腭裂手术培训中具有重要作用。负担得起的、简单的模拟模型,类似于人体组织,对于外科医生在初次培训和对活婴进行手术之间安全地练习技能至关重要。