From the Departments of Neurology (J.D., J.M.) and Psychiatry (J.E.), Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT.
Neurology. 2022 Mar 29;98(13):e1397-e1405. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000200031. Epub 2022 Jan 31.
Enhancing resident well-being has become a top priority for medical educators as awareness of physician burnout continues to grow. Although substantial effort has been made to understand contributors to resident burnout and develop effective interventions, relatively little is known about what characterizes the opposite of burnout-that is, thriving in medical training. This phenomenologic qualitative study applies appreciative inquiry as an interview technique with the aim of characterizing self-identified experiences of thriving among residents in the Yale Neurology program.
Eight residents across all years of training in a single neurology residency participated in semi-structured appreciative interviews to identify experiences of thriving during neurology training. These interviews were transcribed and qualitatively analyzed with a phenomenologic perspective for common themes.
Numerous themes emerged spanning personal, interpersonal, and organizational domains. Whereas some of these themes were congruent with established foundations of well-being and adult learning theory, others revealed the crucial contributions of stress and challenge to thriving. One of the strongest emergent themes was the tendency of residents to thrive during autonomous, high-challenge, high-stress situations, provided that adequate support was present and psychological safety was ensured.
These findings resonate with phenomena studied in positive psychology that are not being widely applied in medical education. To the degree that conclusions are transferable to other training contexts, this study suggests an opportunity for medical educators to harness the positive aspects of stress and challenge in a supportive way that facilitates trainee well-being through experiences of thriving.
随着对医生倦怠感的认识不断提高,提高住院医师的幸福感已成为医学教育者的首要任务。尽管已经做出了很大的努力来了解导致住院医师倦怠的因素并开发有效的干预措施,但对于什么是与倦怠相反的特征,即医疗培训中的茁壮成长,相对而言了解较少。本现象学定性研究采用欣赏性探究作为访谈技术,旨在描述耶鲁神经科住院医师计划中自我认同的住院医师茁壮成长的经历。
在一个单一的神经科住院医师培训项目中,共有 8 名处于培训各个阶段的住院医师参加了半结构化的欣赏性访谈,以确定在神经科培训期间的茁壮成长经历。这些访谈被转录,并从现象学的角度进行了定性分析,以寻找共同的主题。
出现了许多主题,涵盖了个人、人际和组织领域。虽然其中一些主题与幸福感和成人学习理论的既定基础一致,但其他主题则揭示了压力和挑战对茁壮成长的重要贡献。一个最强烈的主题是,只要有足够的支持和确保心理安全,住院医师在自主、高挑战、高压力的情况下有茁壮成长的倾向。
这些发现与积极心理学研究的现象产生共鸣,而这些现象在医学教育中并没有得到广泛应用。在结论可以转移到其他培训环境的程度上,这项研究表明,医学教育者有机会以支持的方式利用压力和挑战的积极方面,通过茁壮成长的经历促进学员的幸福感。