Frith P A, Jenner B, Dangerfield R, Atkinson J, Drennan C
Chest. 1986 Feb;89(2):249-53. doi: 10.1378/chest.89.2.249.
The efficacy and side effects of oxitropium bromide, a new anticholinergic bronchodilator drug, were tested in a double-blind placebo-control study. Twenty-four men, aged 58 to 72 years, with chronic partially reversible obstruction of the airways were used as subjects. Three doses of oxitropium were tested (100 micrograms, 200 micrograms, and 300 micrograms) to determine the optimum dose by metered-dose inhaler. A comparison was also made between oxitropium, fenoterol (400 micrograms), and a combination of oxitropium (200 micrograms) and fenoterol (400 micrograms). Fenoterol produced a greater degree of maximal bronchodilatation than each of the three doses of oxitropium, and its effect was more rapid in onset (30 vs 120 minutes to peak effect); however, the duration of action of oxitropium was greater than that of fenoterol (ie, the forced expiratory volume in one second [FEV1] remained within 5 percent of peak FEV1 for three hours, compared to one hour). Oxitropium in the 100 micrograms dose was inferior to 200 micrograms and 300 micrograms in subjective efficacy scores, peak percent change in FEV1, forced vital capacity, (FVC), mean forced expiratory flow over the middle half of the FVC, and duration of action; there was no difference between 200 micrograms and 300 micrograms. The oxitropium-fenoterol combination had a rapid onset of action, and a greater peak effect was achieved than for oxitropium alone. The main unwanted effect was a mildly unpleasant taste. Anticholinergic effects were not seen in this group of elderly men. Oxitropium bromide therefore is an effective bronchodilator with slow onset but prolonged activity and few side effects when used in patients with moderately severe obstruction of the airways. An appropriate dose appears to be 200 micrograms. Addition of oxitropium to fenoterol appears to offer even greater efficacy.
在一项双盲安慰剂对照研究中,对新型抗胆碱能支气管扩张剂奥昔托溴铵的疗效和副作用进行了测试。选取了24名年龄在58至72岁之间、患有慢性部分可逆性气道阻塞的男性作为研究对象。测试了三种剂量的奥昔托溴铵(100微克、200微克和300微克),以通过定量吸入器确定最佳剂量。还对奥昔托溴铵、非诺特罗(400微克)以及奥昔托溴铵(200微克)与非诺特罗(400微克)的组合进行了比较。非诺特罗产生的最大支气管扩张程度比三种剂量的奥昔托溴铵中的任何一种都要大,且其起效更快(达到峰值效应的时间为30分钟,而奥昔托溴铵为120分钟);然而,奥昔托溴铵的作用持续时间比非诺特罗更长(即一秒用力呼气量[FEV1]在三小时内保持在峰值FEV1的5%以内,而非诺特罗为一小时)。100微克剂量的奥昔托溴铵在主观疗效评分、FEV1的峰值变化百分比、用力肺活量(FVC)、FVC中半程的平均用力呼气流量以及作用持续时间方面均不如200微克和300微克剂量;200微克和300微克剂量之间没有差异。奥昔托溴铵 - 非诺特罗组合起效迅速,且达到的峰值效应比单独使用奥昔托溴铵时更大。主要的不良影响是有轻微的不愉快味道。在这组老年男性中未观察到抗胆碱能作用。因此,奥昔托溴铵是一种有效的支气管扩张剂,起效缓慢但作用持久,用于中度严重气道阻塞患者时副作用较少。合适的剂量似乎是200微克。将奥昔托溴铵与非诺特罗联合使用似乎能提供更高的疗效。