Hwang Chulhwan, Kim Jung Hoon
Department of Radiology, Masan University, Naeseo-eup, MasanHoewon-gu, Changwon-si, Gyeongsangnam-do, Republic of Korea.
Department of Radiological Science, College of Health Sciences, Catholic University of Pusan, Geumjeong-gu, Busan, Republic of Korea.
Transl Cancer Res. 2019 Aug;8(4):1449-1456. doi: 10.21037/tcr.2019.07.54.
The proton therapy is a form of particle radiation therapy that dose enhancement to improve therapeutic ratio (TR) is obtained by high-Z materials. This study evaluated the physical properties of dose enhancement and the resulting changes in the secondary particle production using the spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP).
Monte Carlo simulations were performed using the Geant4 software and the medical internal radiation dose head phantom. Gold and gadolinium were applied as enhancement materials at concentrations of 10, 20, and 30 mg/g in the tumor volume, and the composition of soft tissue was varied in parallel. The ratio of changes in the reaction caused by the interaction of the initial particles with the enhancement materials was calculated.
Among the physical interaction processes, inelastic Coulomb scattering by electrical action occurred with the highest frequency of 99.02%, and elastic collisions, nuclear inelastic collisions, and multiple Coulomb scatterings appeared with low frequencies of 0.633%, 0.334%, and 0.006%, respectively. The use of gold as the enhancement material increased the frequency of interactions by a factor of 1.14-1.18 for inelastic Coulomb scattering, 1.05-1.30 for elastic collision, and 1.03-1.37 for nuclear inelastic collision. Furthermore, the use of gadolinium as the enhancement material increased the frequency of interactions by a factor of 1.08-1.14 for inelastic Coulomb scattering, 1.03-1.25 for elastic collision, and 1.01-1.34 for nuclear inelastic collision. Regarding the dose by the production of secondary particles, the equivalent dose increased by a factor of 1.032-1.070 for alpha particles, 1.133-1.860 for neutrons, and 1.030-1.053 for deuterons when gold was used as the enhancement material. When gadolinium was used as the enhancement material, the equivalent dose increased by a factor of 1.015-1.043 for alpha particles, 1.075-1.478 for neutrons, and 1.021-1.036 for deuterons.
Based on this study's findings, the dose enhancement simulations correspond to the physical characteristics of energy transmission. The study's results can be used as basic data for and experiments investigating the effects of dose enhancement.
质子治疗是一种粒子放射治疗形式,通过高原子序数材料实现剂量增强以提高治疗比(TR)。本研究使用扩展布拉格峰(SOBP)评估了剂量增强的物理特性以及次级粒子产生的相应变化。
使用Geant4软件和医学内部辐射剂量头部体模进行蒙特卡罗模拟。在肿瘤体积中,将金和钆作为增强材料,浓度分别为10、20和30mg/g,并同时改变软组织的组成。计算初始粒子与增强材料相互作用引起的反应变化率。
在物理相互作用过程中,电作用引起的非弹性库仑散射发生频率最高,为99.02%,弹性碰撞、核非弹性碰撞和多次库仑散射出现频率较低,分别为0.633%、0.334%和0.006%。使用金作为增强材料时,非弹性库仑散射的相互作用频率增加1.14 - 1.18倍,弹性碰撞增加1.05 - 1.30倍,核非弹性碰撞增加1.03 - 1.37倍。此外,使用钆作为增强材料时,非弹性库仑散射的相互作用频率增加1.08 - 1.14倍,弹性碰撞增加1.03 - 1.25倍,核非弹性碰撞增加1.01 - 1.34倍。关于次级粒子产生的剂量,当使用金作为增强材料时,α粒子的当量剂量增加1.032 - 1.070倍,中子增加1.133 - 1.860倍,氘核增加1.030 - 1.053倍。当使用钆作为增强材料时,α粒子的当量剂量增加1.015 - 1.043倍,中子增加1.075 - 1.478倍,氘核增加1.021 - 1.036倍。
基于本研究结果,剂量增强模拟与能量传输的物理特性相符。该研究结果可作为研究剂量增强效应的实验的基础数据。