Sahay Rahul, Budiman Arief S, Aziz Izzat, Navarro Etienne, Escoubas Stéphanie, Cornelius Thomas W, Gunawan Fergyanto E, Harito Christian, Lee Pooi See, Thomas Olivier, Raghavan Nagarajan
Xtreme Materials Lab, Engineering Product Development, Singapore University of Technology and Design (SUTD), Singapore 487372, Singapore.
Industrial Engineering Department, BINUS Graduate Program, Bina Nusantara University, Jakarta 11480, Indonesia.
Nanomaterials (Basel). 2022 Jan 18;12(3):308. doi: 10.3390/nano12030308.
Nanolaminates are extensively studied due to their unique properties, such as impact resistance, high fracture toughness, high strength, and resistance to radiation damage. Varieties of nanolaminates are being fabricated to achieve high strength and fracture toughness. In this study, one such nanolaminate fabricated through accumulative roll bonding (Cu(16)/Nb(16) ARB nanolaminate, where 16 nm is the layer thickness) was used as a test material. Cu(16)/Nb(16) ARB nanolaminate exhibits crystallographic anisotropy due to the existence of distinct interfaces along the rolling direction (RD) and the transverse direction (TD). Nanoindentation was executed using a Berkovich tip, with the main axis oriented either along TD or RD of the Cu(16)/Nb(16) ARB nanolaminate. Subsequently, height profiles were obtained along the main axis of the Berkovich indent for both TD and RD using scanning probe microscopy (SPM), which was later used to estimate the pile-up along the RD and TD. The RD exhibited more pile-up than the TD due to the anisotropy of the Cu(16)/Nb(16) ARB interface and the material plasticity along the TD and RD. An axisymmetric 2D finite element analysis (FEA) was also performed to compare/validate nanoindentation data, such as load vs. displacement curves and pile-up. The FEA simulated load vs. displacement curves matched relatively well with the experimentally generated load-displacement curves, while qualitative agreement was found between the simulated pile-up data and the experimentally obtained pile-up data. The authors believe that pile-up characterization during indentation is of great importance to documenting anisotropy in nanolaminates.
由于其独特的性能,如抗冲击性、高断裂韧性、高强度和抗辐射损伤,纳米层压板受到了广泛研究。人们正在制造各种纳米层压板以实现高强度和断裂韧性。在本研究中,一种通过累积轧制粘结制备的纳米层压板(Cu(16)/Nb(16)ARB纳米层压板,其中16nm为层厚)被用作测试材料。由于沿轧制方向(RD)和横向(TD)存在明显的界面,Cu(16)/Nb(16)ARB纳米层压板表现出晶体学各向异性。使用Berkovich压头进行纳米压痕试验,其主轴方向沿Cu(16)/Nb(16)ARB纳米层压板的TD或RD方向。随后,使用扫描探针显微镜(SPM)沿着Berkovich压痕的主轴分别获取TD和RD方向的高度轮廓,该轮廓随后用于估计RD和TD方向的堆积情况。由于Cu(16)/Nb(16)ARB界面各向异性以及沿TD和RD方向的材料塑性,RD方向的堆积比TD方向更多。还进行了轴对称二维有限元分析(FEA)以比较/验证纳米压痕数据,如载荷-位移曲线和堆积情况。FEA模拟的载荷-位移曲线与实验生成的载荷-位移曲线匹配得相对较好,同时模拟的堆积数据与实验获得的堆积数据之间存在定性一致性。作者认为,压痕过程中的堆积表征对于记录纳米层压板的各向异性非常重要。