Schmiedhofer Martina, Derksen Christina, Dietl Johanna Elisa, Häussler Freya, Louwen Frank, Hüner Beate, Reister Frank, Strametz Reinhard, Lippke Sonia
German Coalition for Patient Safety (Aktionsbündnis Patientensicherheit), 10179 Berlin, Germany.
Department of Psychology & Methods, Jacobs University Bremen GmbH, 28759 Bremen, Germany.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Jan 28;19(3):1486. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19031486.
The COVID-19 pandemic and the necessary containment measures challenge obstetric care. Support persons were excluded while protection measures burdened and disrupted the professionals' ability to care and communicate. The objective of this study was to explore the first-hand experience of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on mothers, their partners, and obstetric professionals regarding birth and obstetric care in a university hospital.
To answer the descriptive research questions, we conducted a qualitative content analysis using a data triangulation approach. We carried out 35 semi-structured interviews with two stratified purposive samples. Sample one consisted of 25 mothers who had given birth during the pandemic and five partners. Sample two included 10 obstetric professionals whose insights complemented the research findings and contributed to data validation. Participants were recruited from the study sample of a larger project on patient safety from two German university hospitals from February to August 2021. The study was approved by two ethics committees and informed consent was obtained.
Mothers complied with the rules, but felt socially isolated and insecure, especially before transfer to the delivery room. The staff equally reported burdens from their professional perspective: They tried to make up for the lack of partner and social contacts but could not live up to their usual professional standards. The exclusion of partners was seen critically, but necessary to contain the pandemic. The undisturbed time for bonding in the maternity ward was considered positive by both mothers and professionals.
The negative effects of risk mitigation measures on childbirth are to be considered carefully when containment measures are applied.
新冠疫情及必要的防控措施给产科护理带来了挑战。陪产人员被禁止进入,同时防护措施给医护人员的护理和沟通能力带来了负担并造成了干扰。本研究的目的是探讨新冠疫情对大学医院中母亲、其伴侣及产科专业人员在分娩和产科护理方面影响的第一手经验。
为回答描述性研究问题,我们采用数据三角剖分法进行了定性内容分析。我们对两个分层的目的样本进行了35次半结构化访谈。样本一包括25名在疫情期间分娩的母亲和5名伴侣。样本二包括10名产科专业人员,他们的见解补充了研究结果并有助于数据验证。参与者于2021年2月至8月从两家德国大学医院的一个关于患者安全的较大项目的研究样本中招募。该研究获得了两个伦理委员会的批准并取得了知情同意。
母亲们遵守规定,但感到社交孤立和不安全,尤其是在被送往产房之前。工作人员从他们的专业角度同样报告了负担:他们试图弥补伴侣和社交接触的缺失,但无法达到他们通常的专业标准。伴侣被禁止进入受到了批评,但对控制疫情是必要的。母亲和专业人员都认为产房里不受干扰的母婴亲密接触时间是积极的。
在实施防控措施时,应仔细考虑降低风险措施对分娩的负面影响。