Durieux Brigitte N, Berrier Anna, Catzen Hannah Z, Gray Tamryn F, Lakin Joshua R, Cunningham Rebecca, Morris Sue E, Tulsky James A, Sanders Justin J
Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, MA, USA.
Gillings School of Global Public Health at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
Palliat Med. 2022 Apr;36(4):742-750. doi: 10.1177/02692163221078472. Epub 2022 Feb 15.
Experts consider goal-concordant care an important healthcare outcome for individuals with serious illness. Despite their relationship to the patient and knowledge about the patient's wishes and values, little is known about bereaved family caregivers' perceptions of how end-of-life care aligns with patient goals and preferences.
To understand caregivers' perceptions about patients' care experiences, the extent to which care was perceived as goal-concordant, and the factors that contextualized the end-of-life care experience.
Qualitative interview study employing a semi-structured interview guide based on the National Health and Aging Trends Survey end-of-life planning module. Template analysis was used to identify themes.
SETTING/PARTICIPANTS: Nineteen recently bereaved family caregivers of people with serious illness in two academic medical centers in the Northeastern United States.
Most caregivers reported goal-concordant care, though many also recalled experiences of goal discordance. Three themes characterized care perceptions and related to perceived quality: communication, relationships and humanistic care, and care transitions. Within communication, caregivers described the importance of clear communication, inadequate prognostic communication, and information gaps that undermined caregiver confidence in decision making. Patient-clinician relationships enriched care and were considered higher-quality when felt to be humanistic. Finally, care transitions impacted goal discordance when marked by logistical barriers, a need to establish relationships with new providers, inadequate information transfer, and poor care coordination.
Bereaved caregivers commonly rated care as goal-concordant while also identifying areas of disappointing and low-quality care. Communication, relationships and humanistic care, and care transitions are modifiable quality improvement targets for patients with advanced cancer.
专家认为目标一致的照护是重症患者重要的医疗保健成果。尽管医护人员与患者有关系且了解患者的愿望和价值观,但对于失去亲人的家庭照护者如何看待临终照护与患者目标及偏好的契合度,我们知之甚少。
了解照护者对患者照护经历的看法、照护被视为目标一致的程度,以及影响临终照护经历的因素。
采用基于《国家健康与老龄化趋势调查》临终规划模块的半结构化访谈指南进行定性访谈研究。使用模板分析法确定主题。
背景/参与者:美国东北部两个学术医疗中心的19名近期失去亲人的重症患者家庭照护者。
大多数照护者报告称照护与目标一致,不过许多人也回忆起了目标不一致的经历。有三个主题描述了对照护的看法并与感知到的质量相关:沟通、关系与人文关怀以及照护过渡。在沟通方面,照护者描述了清晰沟通的重要性、预后沟通不足以及信息缺口,这些削弱了照护者决策的信心。患者与临床医生的关系丰富了照护内容,当被认为具有人文关怀时,这种关系被视为更高质量。最后,当存在后勤障碍、需要与新的医护人员建立关系、信息传递不足以及照护协调不佳时,照护过渡会影响目标不一致的情况。
失去亲人的照护者通常将照护评为与目标一致,同时也指出了令人失望和低质量照护的领域。沟通、关系与人文关怀以及照护过渡是晚期癌症患者可改进的质量提升目标。