Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, Nanyang Technological University Singapore, Nanyang, Singapore.
Tan Tock Seng Hospital, Tan Tock Seng, Singapore.
BMC Med Educ. 2022 Feb 14;22(1):99. doi: 10.1186/s12909-022-03159-3.
Studies report that medical graduates are not prepared for practice as expected, and interventions have been developed to prepare them for practice. One such intervention is the assistantship, which provides hands-on opportunities to hone clinical skills and undertake responsibilities under supervision. The Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine (LKCMed) is Singapore's newest medical school, and students undergo a Student Assistantship Programme (SAP) to prepare for practice as junior doctors (PGY1). This study evaluated the SAP from the students' and clinical supervisors' perspectives.
Students completed online questionnaires to assess readiness for practice before and after SAP, and a subsample were interviewed about their experiences of SAP and its impact on their preparedness for PGY1. In addition, after our graduates had begun work as PGY1 doctors, their clinical supervisors completed an online questionnaire and were interviewed about the perceived benefits of SAP and the attributes of our graduates as junior doctors.
Fifty (96%) students completed the pre-SAP questionnaire and 46 (92%) completed the post-SAP questionnaire. Levels of preparedness increased post-SAP (mean scores range pre-SAP: 2.38 to 4.32 vs post-SAP: 3.08 to 4.48); so did opportunities to undertake PGY1 duties (pre-SAP: 56% vs post-SAP: 96%), and hands-on experience in medical emergencies (pre-SAP: 76% vs post-SAP: 89%).Experience of acute care situations increased except "paracetamol overdose". Readiness to be first respondents in ten acute situations improved (statistically significant for asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease exacerbation, gastrointestinal bleed, sepsis, and adverse drug reactions). Three themes emerged from twenty-five student interviews: learning about the work environment, opportunities to learn in a safe environment, and enhancing SAP for future students. Thirty-three supervisors completed the questionnaire, and 70% rated SAP positively in preparing students for PGY1. Eight supervisors interviewed shared positively about the content, timing, and duration of SAP; and suggested future SAPs help students to develop coping and reflective skills.
The SAP improved students' preparedness and experience across clinical areas, and students felt the SAP helped bridge undergraduate curriculum and work, provided opportunities to hone their skills and learn from junior doctors. Most clinical supervisors rated the SAP effective in preparing students for PGY1. This is the first formal evaluation of an assistantship in Singapore, and the findings are encouraging from the perspective of students and PGY1 supervisors.
研究表明,医学毕业生的实际工作能力未达到预期,因此已经开发了干预措施来帮助他们做好实践准备。助理实习就是其中一种干预措施,它为医学生提供了在监督下磨练临床技能和承担职责的实践机会。李政道医学院(LKCMed)是新加坡最新的医学院,学生在完成实习医生(PGY1)培训之前需要参加学生助理计划(SAP)。本研究从学生和临床导师的角度评估了 SAP。
学生在参加 SAP 之前和之后完成了在线问卷,以评估他们对实践的准备情况,其中一小部分学生接受了关于他们对 SAP 的经验及其对 PGY1 准备情况的影响的采访。此外,我们的毕业生开始担任 PGY1 医生后,他们的临床导师完成了一份在线问卷,并接受了采访,以了解 SAP 的益处以及我们的毕业生作为初级医生的特点。
共有 50 名(96%)学生完成了 SAP 前的问卷,46 名(92%)学生完成了 SAP 后的问卷。SAP 后,学生的准备水平提高(平均得分范围 SAP 前:2.38 至 4.32 与 SAP 后:3.08 至 4.48);承担 PGY1 职责的机会增加(SAP 前:56%与 SAP 后:96%),以及在医疗紧急情况下的实践经验增加(SAP 前:76%与 SAP 后:89%)。除“扑热息痛过量”外,急性护理情况的经验增加。十种急性情况的第一响应准备情况有所改善(哮喘、慢性阻塞性肺疾病加重、胃肠道出血、脓毒症和药物不良反应有统计学意义)。从 25 名学生的访谈中出现了三个主题:了解工作环境、在安全环境中学习的机会以及为未来学生增强 SAP。33 名导师完成了问卷,其中 70%的人对 SAP 为学生做好 PGY1 准备的能力给予了积极评价。8 名接受采访的导师对 SAP 的内容、时间安排和持续时间表示赞赏,并建议未来的 SAP 帮助学生发展应对和反思技能。
SAP 提高了学生在各个临床领域的准备情况和经验,学生们认为 SAP 帮助他们弥合了本科课程和工作之间的差距,为他们提供了磨练技能和向初级医生学习的机会。大多数临床导师认为 SAP 有助于学生为 PGY1 做好准备。这是对新加坡助理实习的首次正式评估,从学生和 PGY1 导师的角度来看,结果令人鼓舞。