Ashwal Eran, Ferreira Fabiana, Mei-Dan Elad, Aviram Amir, Sherman Christopher, Zaltz Arthur, Kingdom John, Melamed Nir
Division of Maternal-Fetal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Hamilton Health Sciences, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
Division of Maternal-Fetal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Placenta. 2022 Mar 24;120:40-48. doi: 10.1016/j.placenta.2022.02.007. Epub 2022 Feb 15.
Fetoplacental Doppler is considered to be a key tool for the diagnosis of placenta-mediated fetal growth restriction(FGR). We aimed to determine the diagnostic accuracy of fetoplacental Doppler for specific placental diseases.
A retrospective cohort study of all women with a singleton pregnancy and an antenatal diagnosis of SGA fetus(estimated fetal weight <10th centile for gestational age), who underwent fetoplacental Doppler assessment within 2 weeks before birth. Primary exposure was any abnormal Doppler result, defined as an abnormal umbilical artery(UA) Doppler, middle cerebral artery(MCA) Doppler, cerebroplacental-ratio(CPR), or umbilico-cerebral ratio(UCR). Study outcomes were abnormal placental pathology: maternal vascular malperfusion(MVM), villitis of unknown etiology(VUE), or fetal vascular malperfusion(FVM).
A total of 558 women with a singleton SGA fetus were included, of whom 239(42.8%) had an abnormal fetoplacental Doppler findings. UA Doppler had the lowest detection rate for abnormal placental pathology. MCA Doppler exhibited a significantly higher detection rate for all types of pathology. CPR and UCR exhibited highest detection rates for all types of placental pathology, however, were also associated with the highest false positive rate. The combination of fetoplacental Doppler with the severity of SGA and maternal hypertensive status achieved a high negative predictive value MVM lesions(97%). In contrast, fetoplacental Doppler did not improve the negative predictive value for non-MVM pathology(VUE or FVM).
Among SGA fetuses, the combination of UA and MCA Doppler is highly accurate in ruling out FGR due to MVM placental pathology, but is of limited value in excluding FGR due to underlying non-MVM pathologies.
胎儿胎盘多普勒检查被认为是诊断胎盘介导的胎儿生长受限(FGR)的关键工具。我们旨在确定胎儿胎盘多普勒检查对特定胎盘疾病的诊断准确性。
对所有单胎妊娠且产前诊断为小于胎龄儿(估计胎儿体重低于孕周的第10百分位数)、在出生前2周内接受胎儿胎盘多普勒评估的妇女进行回顾性队列研究。主要暴露因素为任何异常的多普勒检查结果,定义为脐动脉(UA)多普勒、大脑中动脉(MCA)多普勒、脑胎盘比率(CPR)或脐脑比率(UCR)异常。研究结局为胎盘病理异常:母体血管灌注不良(MVM)、不明原因绒毛炎(VUE)或胎儿血管灌注不良(FVM)。
共纳入558名单胎小于胎龄儿的妇女,其中239名(42.8%)胎儿胎盘多普勒检查结果异常。UA多普勒对胎盘病理异常的检出率最低。MCA多普勒对所有类型病理的检出率显著更高。CPR和UCR对所有类型胎盘病理的检出率最高,但假阳性率也最高。胎儿胎盘多普勒检查与小于胎龄儿的严重程度及母体高血压状态相结合,对MVM病变具有较高的阴性预测值(97%)。相比之下,胎儿胎盘多普勒检查并未提高对非MVM病理(VUE或FVM)的阴性预测值。
在小于胎龄儿中,UA和MCA多普勒检查相结合在排除因MVM胎盘病理导致的FGR方面具有高度准确性,但在排除因潜在非MVM病理导致的FGR方面价值有限。