Department of Cardiology, Barts Heart Centre, Barts Health NHS Trust, London, UK; Cardiovascular Devices Hub, Centre for Cardiovascular Medicine and Devices, William Harvey Research Institute, Queen Mary University of London, UK.
Division of Imaging Processing, Department of Radiology, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, the Netherlands.
Atherosclerosis. 2022 Mar;345:15-25. doi: 10.1016/j.atherosclerosis.2022.01.021. Epub 2022 Jan 29.
Accurate classification of plaque composition is essential for treatment planning. Intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) has limited efficacy in assessing tissue types, while near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) provides complementary information to IVUS but lacks depth information. The aim of this study is to train and assess the efficacy of a machine learning classifier for plaque component classification that relies on IVUS echogenicity and NIRS-signal, using histology as reference standard.
Matched NIRS-IVUS and histology images from 15 cadaveric human coronary arteries were analyzed (10 vessels were used for training and 5 for testing). Fibrous/pathological intimal thickening (F-PIT), early necrotic core (ENC), late necrotic core (LNC), and calcific tissue regions-of-interest were detected on histology and superimposed onto IVUS frames. The pixel intensities of these tissue types from the training set were used to train a J48 classifier for plaque characterization (ECHO-classification). To aid differentiation of F-PIT from necrotic cores, the NIRS-signal was used to classify non-calcific pixels outside yellow-spot regions as F-PIT (ECHO-NIRS classification). The performance of ECHO and ECHO-NIRS classifications were validated against histology.
262 matched frames were included in the analysis (162 constituted the training set and 100 the test set). The pixel intensities of F-PIT and ENC were similar and thus these two tissues could not be differentiated by echogenicity. With ENC and LNC as a single class, ECHO-classification showed good agreement with histology for detecting calcific and F-PIT tissues but had poor efficacy for necrotic cores (recall 0.59 and precision 0.29). Similar results were found when F-PIT and ENC were treated as a single class (recall and precision for LNC 0.78 and 0.33, respectively). ECHO-NIRS classification improved necrotic core and LNC detection, resulting in an increase of the overall accuracy of both models, from 81.4% to 91.8%, and from 87.9% to 94.7%, respectively. Comparable performance of the two models was seen in the test set where the overall accuracy of ECHO-NIRS classification was 95.0% and 95.5%, respectively.
The combination of echogenicity with NIRS-signal appears capable of overcoming limitations of echogenicity, enabling more accurate characterization of plaque components.
准确的斑块成分分类对于治疗计划至关重要。血管内超声(IVUS)在评估组织类型方面的效果有限,而近红外光谱(NIRS)则提供了 IVUS 的补充信息,但缺乏深度信息。本研究旨在训练和评估一种基于 IVUS 回声和 NIRS 信号的斑块成分分类机器学习分类器的疗效,以组织学为参考标准。
对 15 例人尸检冠状动脉的匹配 NIRS-IVUS 和组织学图像进行分析(10 个血管用于训练,5 个用于测试)。在组织学上检测纤维/病理性内膜增厚(F-PIT)、早期坏死核(ENC)、晚期坏死核(LNC)和钙化组织感兴趣区域,并将其叠加到 IVUS 帧上。使用训练集中这些组织类型的像素强度来训练用于斑块特征描述的 J48 分类器(ECHO 分类)。为了帮助区分 F-PIT 和坏死核,使用 NIRS 信号将黄色斑点区域外的非钙化像素分类为 F-PIT(ECHO-NIRS 分类)。ECHO 和 ECHO-NIRS 分类的性能通过与组织学进行验证。
共纳入 262 个匹配的帧进行分析(162 个构成训练集,100 个构成测试集)。F-PIT 和 ENC 的像素强度相似,因此不能通过回声强度来区分这两种组织。将 ENC 和 LNC 作为一个单一的类别,ECHO 分类法在检测钙化和 F-PIT 组织方面与组织学具有良好的一致性,但在检测坏死核方面效果不佳(召回率为 0.59,精度为 0.29)。当将 F-PIT 和 ENC 视为单一类别时,得到了类似的结果(LNC 的召回率和精度分别为 0.78 和 0.33)。ECHO-NIRS 分类提高了坏死核和 LNC 的检测效果,从而提高了两个模型的整体准确性,从 81.4%提高到 91.8%,从 87.9%提高到 94.7%。在测试集中,ECHO-NIRS 分类的整体准确性分别为 95.0%和 95.5%,两种模型的性能相当。
回声强度与 NIRS 信号的结合似乎能够克服回声强度的局限性,从而能够更准确地描述斑块成分。