Centre for Ecology, Evolution & Behaviour, Department of Biological Sciences, School of Life Sciences and the Environment, Royal Holloway University of London, London TW20 0EX, UK.
NIAB EMR, New Road, East Malling, Kent ME19 6RN, UK.
Bull Entomol Res. 2022 Aug;112(4):451-457. doi: 10.1017/S0007485321001115. Epub 2022 Feb 24.
Aphidophagous hoverflies (Diptera, Syrphidae, Syrphinae) are common flower visitors and aphid predators in a range of flowering plants, including fruit crops. Here, we investigate whether aphid prey DNA can be detected in the gut contents of hoverfly larvae from a commercial strawberry field as a proof of concept that a molecular approach can be used to measure agricultural biocontrol. We used high-throughput sequencing (HTS) to target insect DNA and compared the resulting data to reference databases containing aphid and hoverfly DNA sequences. We explored what impact incorporating wildflowers within polythene-clad tunnels may have on aphid DNA detection rates in hoverfly larvae. In a randomized block experiment, coriander (), field forget-me-not () and corn mint () plants were inserted in rows of strawberries. Their effect on aphid DNA detection rates was assessed. Aphid DNA was found in 55 of 149 specimens (37%) validating the method in principle for measuring agricultural services provided by hoverflies. Interestingly, detection rates were higher near plots with forget-me-not than plots with coriander, though detection rates in control plots did not differ significantly from either wildflower species. These findings confirm that hoverflies predate aphids in UK strawberry fields, and that HTS is a viable method of identifying aphid DNA in predatory hoverflies. We comment on the need for further method development to narrow down identifications of both predator and prey. We furthermore provide some evidence that there is an effect of intercropping strawberry crops with wildflowers which may affect aphid consumption in hoverfly larvae.
食蚜虻(双翅目,蝇科,食蚜蝇亚科)是多种开花植物(包括水果作物)中常见的访花昆虫和蚜虫捕食者。在这里,我们研究了商业草莓田中食蚜蝇幼虫的肠道内容物中是否可以检测到蚜虫猎物 DNA,以证明分子方法可用于测量农业生物防治。我们使用高通量测序(HTS)靶向昆虫 DNA,并将得到的数据与包含蚜虫和食蚜蝇 DNA 序列的参考数据库进行比较。我们探讨了在聚乙烯覆盖的隧道内种植野花对食蚜蝇幼虫中蚜虫 DNA 检测率的可能影响。在随机区组实验中,将香菜()、田野勿忘草()和玉米薄荷()植物插入草莓行中。评估了它们对蚜虫 DNA 检测率的影响。在 149 个标本中有 55 个(37%)检测到了蚜虫 DNA,这从原理上验证了该方法用于测量食蚜蝇提供的农业服务的有效性。有趣的是,与种植香菜的地块相比,种植勿忘草的地块中蚜虫 DNA 的检测率更高,而对照地块中的检测率与这两种野花都没有显著差异。这些发现证实了食蚜蝇在英国草莓田中捕食蚜虫,并且 HTS 是鉴定捕食性食蚜蝇中蚜虫 DNA 的可行方法。我们评论了需要进一步开发方法来缩小对捕食者和猎物的鉴定。此外,我们提供了一些证据表明,草莓作物与野花间作会影响食蚜蝇幼虫中蚜虫的消耗。