Maini C L, Bonetti M G, Giordano A, Pistelli R, Antonelli Incalzi R, Vecchioli A, Galli G
Radiol Med. 1986 Apr;72(4):204-9.
Papers on deposition pattern analyses of radio-aerosol lung scans are few and not easy to interpret as there is a general lack of technical standardization and the number of patients studied is not large. Moreover these reports have been generally obtained with non-hydrosoluble radioaerosols. In the present study 43 patients underwent conventional pulmonary function testing and lung scanning using small droplet (equal or less than 2 microns) polydisperse 99mTc-DTPA radioaerosol produced with the "Settling Bag System"--Medi 400 (Sorin). The scans were analysed by two methods: a semiquantitative method proposed by Taplin (SQT); an original simpler semiquantitative method (SQM). Correlations of SQT and SQM with FEV1 and MEF75 resulted highly significant (p less than 0,001). SQM proved to be superior to SQT as far as reproducibility is concerned. The following conclusions can be drawn: small particle 99mTc-DTPA aerosol can be easily and cheaply produced by a commercial device; such a radioaerosol is well suited for the evaluation of small and large airways patency, as reflected by MEF75 and FEV1 respectively, with a diagnostic yield comparable to non-hydrosoluble radioaerosols; the original semiquantitative description of the deposition patterns proposed and validated in this study is quite easy to implement and it yields a high correlation with pulmonary function tests; moreover such an approach does not require digital data processing; the sensitivity of 99mTc-DTPA for the diagnosis of bronchial obstruction is very high and superior to routine pulmonary function tests; in addition the ventilation scan allows the topographical localization of the obstructions themselves.
关于放射性气溶胶肺部扫描沉积模式分析的论文很少,且由于普遍缺乏技术标准化以及所研究的患者数量不多,所以难以解读。此外,这些报告通常是使用非水溶性放射性气溶胶获得的。在本研究中,43例患者接受了常规肺功能测试,并使用“Settling Bag System”——Medi 400(索林公司)产生的小液滴(等于或小于2微米)多分散99m锝-二乙三胺五乙酸放射性气溶胶进行肺部扫描。扫描结果通过两种方法进行分析:一种是由塔普林提出的半定量方法(SQT);另一种是一种新颖且更简单的半定量方法(SQM)。SQT和SQM与第一秒用力呼气容积(FEV1)和75%最大呼气流量(MEF75)的相关性非常显著(p小于0.001)。就可重复性而言,SQM被证明优于SQT。可以得出以下结论:小颗粒99m锝-二乙三胺五乙酸气溶胶可通过商用设备轻松且廉价地产生;这种放射性气溶胶非常适合评估大小气道的通畅性,分别由MEF75和FEV1反映,其诊断率与非水溶性放射性气溶胶相当;本研究中提出并验证的沉积模式的新颖半定量描述很容易实施,并且与肺功能测试具有高度相关性;此外,这种方法不需要数字数据处理;99m锝-二乙三胺五乙酸对支气管阻塞的诊断敏感性非常高,优于常规肺功能测试;此外,通气扫描能够对阻塞部位进行定位。