Fan Jian, Shang Yan, Shen Fei, Huang Qiaowen, Wang Ziyu, Han Yiping, Zhao Jiayi
Department of General Practice, Changhai Hospital, Naval Military Medical University, Shanghai, 200433, People's Republic of China.
Yinhang Community Healthcare Center, Shanghai, 200433, People's Republic of China.
Int J Gen Med. 2022 Feb 16;15:1609-1618. doi: 10.2147/IJGM.S339583. eCollection 2022.
Venous thrombosis (VTE) is a high-incidence disease that affects different systems of the body, but no comparative studies have been conducted to explore its incidence in different systems in patients with the coexistence of multiple diseases. Primary care is a medical institution that has the first contact with patients' conditions. The majority of outpatients suffer from multiple diseases, and they are more prone to VTE, which is of significance and requires investigation. At the same time, we observed that the primary care patients' cognition level of VTE is insufficiency at present, and the prevention and management of VTE in China is still in its infancy. Most studies focus on whether doctors and nurses are clear about the diagnosis and manifestations of VTE, however, few studies on patients' cognitive level and influencing factors of symptoms and prevention of VTE. Therefore, it is necessary to study the causes of cognitive deficiency of VTE from the perspective of patients, conduct targeted cognitive and behavioral interventions, and finally achieve the purpose of improving the effect of VTE prevention and management.
This study aimed to explore the risk factors, cognitive level and cognitive potential influence factors of VTE in outpatients of primary care in Shanghai, as well as which diseases, are more likely to promote occurrence of VTE among patients with multiple diseases.
A total of 710 patients were included in the analysis. Shanghai in China is divided into urban and suburban areas by their geographical location, and a random sample of 10 primary care areas was investigated, including 5 urban areas and 5 suburban areas. The Padua scale and the VTE cognitive level-related knowledge test scale were used for the investigation. Statistical software was used to conduct univariate Pearson correlation analysis and multivariate logistic regression analysis for VTE high-risk factors among outpatients of primary care. Furthermore, the high-risk factors for VTE and the types of chronic disease in patients with multiple diseases were subjected to subgroup analyses. -test was used to statistically analyze cognitive level of VTE and the potential influence factors related to the patients' VTE cognitive level.
Univariate analysis of risk factors for VTE in 710 outpatients showed that age ( =83.895, P<0.001), education ( =8.324, P=0.004), region ( =63.936, P<0.001), chronic disease ( =18.198, <0.001) and the coexistence of multiple diseases ( =61.347, <0.001) were the main risk factors for VTE risk in patients. Logistic multivariate regression analysis showed that age, region, chronic diseases and the coexistence of multiple diseases were independent risk factors for VTE risk in patients. The correlation between high risk of VTE in patients with multiple diseases and various types of chronic diseases was further analyzed by logistic multivariate regression. The results showed that diabetes mellitus (OR=1.636 [95% CI, 1.030-2.599], =0.037), cerebral infarction (OR=8.484 [95% CI, 4.615-15.597], P<0.001), coronary heart disease (OR=2.987 [95% CI, 1.699-5.252], <0.001), intracerebral hemorrhage (OR=15.130 [95% CI, 4.707-48.630], <0.001), respiratory diseases (OR=3.470, [95% CI, 1.428-8.43], =0.006) and malignant tumors (OR=4.576, [95% CI, 1.85-11.315], =0.001) were independent risk factors for VTE among patients with co-existing diseases, and the risks from high to low were cerebral hemorrhage>cerebral infarction>malignant tumor>respiratory system disease>coronary heart disease> diabetes. In addition, patients' age (=6.869, P<0.001), region (=3.420, <0.001), education level (=-7.341, <0.001), chronic disease (=5.875, <0.001), BMI (=6.404, =0.012), smoking (=4.152, =0.042) were related to the VTE cognitive level.
General practitioners should pay close attention to independent risk factors for VTE among patients in routine outpatient care, especially patients with co-existing diseases with independent risk for VTE, placing them high risk of VTE. At the same time, health education and other measures should be strengthened to improve the patients' awareness and cognitive level of VTE to prevent the occurrence of VTE and its related complications.
静脉血栓形成(VTE)是一种高发性疾病,可影响身体的不同系统,但尚未有比较研究探讨其在多种疾病并存患者不同系统中的发病率。基层医疗是与患者病情首次接触的医疗机构。大多数门诊患者患有多种疾病,且更易发生VTE,这具有重要意义且需要进行调查。同时,我们观察到目前基层医疗患者对VTE的认知水平不足,我国VTE的预防和管理仍处于起步阶段。大多数研究关注医生和护士是否清楚VTE的诊断和表现,然而,关于患者对VTE症状及预防的认知水平和影响因素的研究较少。因此,有必要从患者角度研究VTE认知不足的原因,进行有针对性的认知和行为干预,最终达到提高VTE预防和管理效果的目的。
本研究旨在探讨上海市基层医疗门诊患者VTE的危险因素、认知水平及认知潜在影响因素,以及在多种疾病患者中哪些疾病更易促进VTE的发生。
共纳入710例患者进行分析。根据地理位置将中国上海分为市区和郊区,随机抽取10个基层医疗区域进行调查,包括5个市区和5个郊区。采用Padua量表和VTE认知水平相关知识测试量表进行调查。运用统计软件对基层医疗门诊患者的VTE高危因素进行单因素Pearson相关分析和多因素Logistic回归分析。此外,对VTE高危因素与多种疾病患者的慢性病类型进行亚组分析。采用t检验对VTE认知水平及与患者VTE认知水平相关的潜在影响因素进行统计学分析。
对710例门诊患者VTE危险因素的单因素分析显示,年龄(χ² =83.895,P<0.001)、教育程度(χ² =8.324,P=0.004)、地区(χ² =63.936,P<0.001)、慢性病(χ² =18.198, P<0.001)和多种疾病并存(χ² =61.347, P<0.001)是患者VTE风险的主要危险因素。Logistic多因素回归分析显示,年龄、地区、慢性病和多种疾病并存是患者VTE风险的独立危险因素。通过Logistic多因素回归进一步分析多种疾病患者中VTE高危与各类慢性病的相关性。结果显示,糖尿病(OR=1.636 [95%CI,1.030 - 2.599],P=0.037)、脑梗死(OR=8.484 [95%CI,4.615 - 15.597],P<0.001)、冠心病(OR=2.987 [95%CI,1.699 - 5.252],P<0.001)、脑出血(OR=15.130 [95%CI,4.707 - 48.630],P<0.001)、呼吸系统疾病(OR=3.470,[95%CI,1.428 - 8.43],P=0.006)和恶性肿瘤(OR=4.576,[95%CI,1.85 - 11.315],P=0.001)是并存疾病患者VTE的独立危险因素,风险由高到低依次为脑出血>脑梗死>恶性肿瘤>呼吸系统疾病>冠心病>糖尿病。此外,患者的年龄(χ² =6.869,P<0.001)、地区(χ² =3.420,P<0.001)、教育水平(χ² = - 7.341,P<0.001)、慢性病(χ² =5.875,P<0.001)、BMI(χ² =6.404,P=