Alegoz Mehmet, Yapicioglu Haluk
Department of Industrial Engineering, Eskisehir Technical University, 26555 Eskisehir, Turkey.
Soft comput. 2022;26(10):4819-4830. doi: 10.1007/s00500-022-06866-7. Epub 2022 Feb 21.
Triple bottom line (TBL) is one of the well-known frameworks for measuring the sustainability of a system in which environmental and social aspects are also considered together with the economic aspect. In this study, we consider the integrated supplier selection, lot sizing and facility location decisions and propose a two-phase decision framework based on TBL approach. In the first phase of the study, we use a trapezoidal type-2 fuzzy AHP algorithm for the initial evaluation of the suppliers based on various economic, environmental and social criteria, whereas in the second phase of the study, we propose a two-stage stochastic programming model for the integrated supplier selection, lot sizing and facility location decisions under supply and demand uncertainties. We also present a real-life case study to test the proposed decision framework. Computational results, on one hand, show the applicability of the proposed decision framework on real-life cases and, on the other hand, bring significant managerial insights. Particularly, we observe that all three pillars (economic, environmental and social) of sustainability are in conflict with each other and thus being both environmentally and socially responsible is much more costlier than being solely environmentally or socially responsible. Moreover, we observe that ignoring the uncertainties in the system may yield to higher costs and impractical results.
三重底线(TBL)是衡量系统可持续性的著名框架之一,该框架将环境和社会方面与经济方面一同考虑。在本研究中,我们考虑集成供应商选择、批量规模确定和设施选址决策,并基于TBL方法提出一个两阶段决策框架。在研究的第一阶段,我们使用梯形2型模糊层次分析法算法,基于各种经济、环境和社会标准对供应商进行初步评估;而在研究的第二阶段,我们针对供需不确定性下的集成供应商选择、批量规模确定和设施选址决策,提出一个两阶段随机规划模型。我们还给出一个实际案例研究来检验所提出的决策框架。计算结果一方面表明所提出的决策框架在实际案例中的适用性,另一方面带来重要的管理见解。特别是,我们观察到可持续性的所有三个支柱(经济、环境和社会)相互冲突,因此兼顾环境和社会责任比只承担环境或社会责任成本更高。此外,我们观察到忽略系统中的不确定性可能导致更高成本和不切实际的结果。