Alvarez Licet, Alves Luana Severo, Fabruccini Anunzziatta, Maltz Marisa
Department of Paediatric Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, University of the Republic, Montevideo, Uruguay.
Department of Restorative Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Federal University of Santa Maria, Santa Maria, Brazil.
Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol. 2022 Jun;133(6):725-732. doi: 10.1016/j.oooo.2022.01.015. Epub 2022 Jan 22.
The aim was to assess the value of sociodemographic, behavioral, and clinical characteristics in identifying adolescents who would benefit from radiographs for dental caries detection in a high-caries experience population.
In total, 356 adolescents answered a validated questionnaire on sociodemographic characteristics and oral health behavior and were clinically and radiographically examined for caries. The outcome was the benefit arising from radiographs for caries detection at the patient level, defined as the number of surfaces clinically classified as sound but presenting radiolucency.
A total of 169 participants (47.5%) benefited from radiographs. One-third of approximal lesions were detected clinically, whereas two-thirds, mostly initial lesions, were detected radiographically only. Adolescents who reported frequent consumption of soft drinks and sugary food, those with DMFS (noncavitated and cavitated caries experience) ≥12, DMFS (cavitated caries experience) ≥1, clinically detected approximal lesions, and active caries were significantly more likely to benefit from radiographs (P ≤ .002). Although some indicators showed moderate-to-good sensitivity (consumption of sugary food, caries activity) or specificity (absence of clinically diagnosed approximal lesions), the accuracy of indicators evaluated (isolated or combined) never reached 0.60.
The possibility of correctly identifying which adolescents would benefit from radiographs for caries detection purposes was limited in a population with high-caries experience.
评估社会人口统计学、行为学和临床特征在识别高龋患率人群中能从龋病检测X线片检查中获益的青少年方面的价值。
共有356名青少年回答了一份关于社会人口统计学特征和口腔健康行为的有效问卷,并接受了龋病的临床和X线片检查。结果是在患者层面上X线片检查对龋病检测的获益情况,定义为临床分类为健康但出现透射影像的牙面数量。
共有169名参与者(47.5%)从X线片检查中获益。三分之一的邻面病变通过临床检查发现,而三分之二,主要是早期病变,仅通过X线片检查发现。报告经常饮用软饮料和食用含糖食物的青少年、DMFS(非龋洞和龋洞性龋患经历)≥12、DMFS(龋洞性龋患经历)≥1、临床检查发现邻面病变以及患有活动性龋病的青少年从X线片检查中获益的可能性显著更高(P≤0.002)。尽管一些指标显示出中度到良好的敏感性(食用含糖食物、龋病活动性)或特异性(无临床诊断的邻面病变),但所评估指标(单独或联合)的准确性从未达到0.60。
在高龋患率人群中,正确识别哪些青少年能从龋病检测X线片检查中获益的可能性有限。