From the Neuroradiology Unit (I.G., F.P., D.A., R.P., C.M., M.G.B.), Scientific Department (F.P.), Epilepsy Unit (R.G., D.D.S., L.R., F.D., M.D.C., G.D.), Neuropathology Unit (G.M.), and Neurosurgery Unit (G.T.), Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Neurologico Carlo Besta, Milano, Italy; and Department of Neuropathology (R.C.), University Hospital Erlangen, Germany.
Neurology. 2022 Apr 26;98(17):e1771-e1782. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000200140. Epub 2022 Mar 7.
The identification of possible hippocampal alterations is a crucial point for the diagnosis and therapy of patients with unilateral temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). This study aims to investigate the role of neurite orientation dispersion and density imaging (NODDI) compared to diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) in the comprehension of hippocampal microstructure in TLE.
DTI and NODDI metrics were calculated in the hippocampi of adult patients with TLE, with and without histology-confirmed hippocampal sclerosis (HS), and in age/sex-matched healthy controls (HC). Diffusion metrics and hippocampal volumes of the pathologic side were compared within participants and between participants among the HS, non-HS, and HC groups. Diffusion metrics were also correlated with hippocampal volume and patients' clinical features. After surgery, hippocampal specimens were processed for neuropathology examinations.
Fifteen patients with TLE (9 with and 6 without HS) and 11 HC were included. Hippocampal analyses resulted in a significant increase in fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean diffusivity (MD; mm/s × 10) and decrease in orientation dispersion index (ODI) comparing the pathologic side of patients with HS and their relative nonpathologic side (0.203 vs 0.183, 0.825 vs 0.724, 0.366 vs 0.443, respectively), the pathologic side of patients without HS (0.203 vs 0.169, 0.825 vs 0.745, 0.366 vs 0.453, respectively), and HC (0.203 vs 0.172, 0.825 vs 0.729, 0.366 vs 0.447, respectively). Moreover, neurite density (ND) was significantly decreased comparing both hippocampi of patients with HS (0.416 vs 0.460). A significant increase in free-water isotropic volume fraction (fiso) was found in the comparison of pathologic hippocampi of patients with HS and nonpathologic hippocampi of patients with HS (0.323 vs 0.258) and HC (0.323 vs 0.226). Hippocampal volume of all patients with TLE negatively correlated with MD ( = -0.746, = 0.0145) and positively correlated with ODI ( = 0.719, = 0.0145). Fiso and ND of sclerotic hippocampi positively correlated with disease duration ( = 0.684, = 0.0424 and = 0.670, = 0.0486, respectively). Immunohistochemistry in sclerotic hippocampal specimens revealed neuronal loss in the pyramidal layer and fiber reorganization at the level of stratum lacunosum-moleculare, confirming ODI and ND metrics.
This study shows the capability of diffusion MRI metrics to detect hippocampal microstructural alterations. Among them, ODI seems to better highlight the fiber reorganization observed by neuropathology in sclerotic hippocampi.
识别海马区可能的改变是单侧颞叶癫痫(TLE)患者诊断和治疗的关键。本研究旨在探讨神经丝取向分散和密度成像(NODDI)与弥散张量成像(DTI)在理解 TLE 中海马微观结构中的作用。
对伴有和不伴有组织学证实的海马硬化(HS)的 TLE 成年患者以及年龄/性别匹配的健康对照者(HC)的海马区进行 DTI 和 NODDI 测量。在参与者内和 HS、非 HS 和 HC 组之间比较病变侧的弥散指标和海马体积。还将弥散指标与海马体积和患者的临床特征进行相关性分析。手术后,对海马标本进行神经病理学检查。
共纳入 15 例 TLE 患者(9 例伴有 HS,6 例不伴有 HS)和 11 例 HC。与 HS 患者的非病变侧相比,HS 患者和非 HS 患者的病变侧的各向异性分数(FA)和平均弥散度(MD;mm/s×10)显著增加,而取向分散指数(ODI)则降低(0.203 比 0.183,0.825 比 0.724,0.366 比 0.443),HS 患者的病变侧和非病变侧(0.203 比 0.169,0.825 比 0.745,0.366 比 0.453),HC(0.203 比 0.172,0.825 比 0.729,0.366 比 0.447)。此外,与 HS 患者的双侧海马相比,神经丝密度(ND)均显著降低(0.416 比 0.460)。HS 患者病变侧的自由水各向同性体积分数(fiso)显著增加,与 HS 患者非病变侧和 HC(0.323 比 0.258 和 0.323 比 0.226)相比。所有 TLE 患者的海马体积与 MD( = -0.746, = 0.0145)呈负相关,与 ODI( = 0.719, = 0.0145)呈正相关。HS 患者的 sclerotic 海马区的 fiso 和 ND 与疾病持续时间呈正相关( = 0.684, = 0.0424 和 = 0.670, = 0.0486)。HS 海马组织学标本的免疫组织化学显示,在锥体细胞层有神经元丢失,在颗粒层-分子层水平有纤维重组,证实了 ODI 和 ND 指标。
本研究显示弥散 MRI 指标能够检测出海马区的微观结构改变。其中,ODI 似乎能更好地突出神经病理学观察到的纤维重组。