M.B. Bolster is associate professor of medicine, Harvard Medical School, and director, Rheumatology Fellowship Training Program, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5413-9345 .
S. Chandra is assistant professor of emergency medicine, Thomas Jefferson University, director of Phase 3, Sidney Kimmel Medical College, and program director, Digital Health and Telehealth Education, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0294-9397 .
Acad Med. 2022 Jun 1;97(6):839-846. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000004660. Epub 2022 Mar 8.
Virtual care, introduced previously as a replacement for in-person visits, is now being integrated into clinical care delivery models to complement in-person visits. The COVID-19 pandemic sped up this process. The rapid uptake of virtual care at the start of the pandemic prevented educators from taking deliberate steps to design the foundational elements of the related learning environment, including workflow, competencies, and assessment methods. Educators must now pursue an informed and purposeful approach to design a curriculum and implement virtual care in the learning environment. Engaging learners in virtual care offers opportunities for novel ways to teach and assess their performance and to effectively integrate technology such that it is accessible and equitable. It also offers opportunities for learners to demonstrate professionalism in a virtual environment, to obtain a patient's history incorporating interpersonal and communication skills, to interact with multiple parties during a patient encounter (patient, caregiver, translator, telepresenter, faculty member), to enhance physical examination techniques via videoconferencing, and ideally to optimize demonstrations of empathy through "webside manner." Feedback and assessment, important features of training in any setting, must be timely, specific, and actionable in the new virtual care environment. Recognizing the importance of integrating virtual care into education, leaders from across the United States convened on September 10, 2020, for a symposium titled, "Crossing the Virtual Chasm: Rethinking Curriculum, Competency, and Culture in the Virtual Care Era." In this article, the authors share recommendations that came out of this symposium for the implementation of educational tools in the evolving virtual care environment. They present core competencies, assessment tools, precepting workflows, and technology to optimize the delivery of high-quality virtual care that is safe, timely, effective, efficient, equitable, and patient-centered.
虚拟医疗保健先前被引入以替代面对面就诊,现在正被整合到临床护理提供模式中,以补充面对面就诊。COVID-19 大流行加速了这一进程。大流行初期虚拟医疗保健的快速普及使得教育工作者无法刻意设计相关学习环境的基本要素,包括工作流程、能力和评估方法。教育工作者现在必须采取明智和有目的的方法来设计课程,并在学习环境中实施虚拟医疗保健。让学习者参与虚拟医疗保健为以新颖的方式教授和评估他们的表现以及有效地整合技术提供了机会,使技术具有可及性和公平性。它还为学习者提供了在虚拟环境中表现出专业精神的机会,在患者就诊期间获取包含人际和沟通技巧的病史,与多方(患者、护理人员、翻译人员、远程呈现人员、教师)互动,通过视频会议增强体检技术,并通过“webside manner”优化同理心的展示。反馈和评估是任何环境中培训的重要特征,在新的虚拟医疗保健环境中必须及时、具体和可操作。认识到将虚拟医疗保健融入教育的重要性,来自美国各地的领导人于 2020 年 9 月 10 日举行了一次名为“跨越虚拟鸿沟:在虚拟医疗保健时代重新思考课程、能力和文化”的研讨会。在本文中,作者分享了此次研讨会提出的在不断发展的虚拟医疗保健环境中实施教育工具的建议。他们提出了核心能力、评估工具、指导工作流程和技术,以优化安全、及时、有效、高效、公平和以患者为中心的高质量虚拟医疗保健的提供。