Department of Pediatrics, Ajou University School of Medicine, Suwon, Korea.
Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Konkuk University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
J Korean Med Sci. 2022 Mar 14;37(10):e77. doi: 10.3346/jkms.2022.37.e77.
Herein, we aimed to evaluate the maternal mortality ratio and perinatal mortality rate for different perinatal medical care service areas (PMCSAs), which were established by considering their geographical accessibility to maternal-fetal intensive care units (MFICUs) and neonatal intensive care units (NICUs), and to compare the PMCSAs according to their accessibility to these perinatal care services.
Based on the 70 hospital service areas (HSAs) across the country confirmed through the Dartmouth Atlas methodology analysis and gathering of expert opinions, the PMCSAs were designated by merging HSAs without MFICUs and NICUs to the nearest HSA that contained MFICUs and NICUs, based on which MFICU and NICU could be reached within the shortest amount of time from population-weighted centroids in HSAs. PMCSAs where 30% or more of the population could not access MFICUs and NICUs within 60 minutes were identified using the service module ArcGIS and were defined as having access vulnerability.
Thirty-three of 70 HSAs in the country did not contain MFICUs and NICUs, and 39 PMCSAs were finally derived by merging 70 HSAs. Ten of 39 PMCSAs (25.6%) were classified as having access vulnerability to MFICUs and NICUs. The national maternal mortality ratio was 9.42, with the highest ratio seen in the region of Wonju (25.86) and the lowest in Goyang (2.79). The national perinatal mortality rate was 2.86, with the highest and lowest rates observed in the Gunsan (4.04) and Sejong (1.99) regions, respectively. The perinatal mortality rates for areas vulnerable and invulnerable to maternal and neonatal healthcare accessibility were 2.97 and 2.92, respectively, but there was no statistically significant difference in this rate ( = 0.789). The maternal mortality ratio for areas vulnerable and invulnerable to maternal and neonatal healthcare accessibility were 14.28 and 9.48, respectively; this ratio was significantly higher in areas vulnerable to accessibility ( = 0.022).
Of the PMCSAs across the country, 25.6% (10/39) were deemed to be vulnerable to MFICU and NICU accessibility. There was no difference in the perinatal mortality rate between the vulnerable and invulnerable areas, but the maternal mortality ratio in vulnerable areas was significantly higher than that in invulnerable areas.
本研究旨在评估不同围产期医疗保健服务区(PMCSAs)的孕产妇死亡率和围产儿死亡率,这些服务区是根据其到孕产妇-胎儿重症监护病房(MFICU)和新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)的地理可达性来设立的,并根据这些围产期保健服务的可达性来比较这些 PMCSAs。
基于通过达特茅斯地图集方法分析和征求专家意见确定的全国 70 个医院服务区(HSAs),通过合并没有 MFICU 和 NICU 的 HSAs 到最近的包含 MFICU 和 NICU 的 HSA,根据这一点,可以在 HSAs 人口加权质心的最短时间内到达 MFICU 和 NICU,从而指定 PMCSAs。使用服务模块 ArcGIS 确定 30%或更多人口在 60 分钟内无法到达 MFICU 和 NICU 的 PMCSAs,并将其定义为具有可达性脆弱性。
全国 70 个 HSAs 中有 33 个不包含 MFICU 和 NICU,最终通过合并 70 个 HSAs 得出 39 个 PMCSAs。其中 10 个(25.6%)被归类为 MFICU 和 NICU 可达性脆弱。全国孕产妇死亡率为 9.42,其中最高的是沃雄(25.86),最低的是高阳(2.79)。全国围产儿死亡率为 2.86,其中最高和最低的分别是群山(4.04)和世宗(1.99)。可达性脆弱和不易达性脆弱的围产儿死亡率分别为 2.97 和 2.92,但差异无统计学意义(=0.789)。可达性脆弱和不易达性脆弱的孕产妇死亡率分别为 14.28 和 9.48,可达性脆弱的孕产妇死亡率明显更高(=0.022)。
全国的 PMCSAs 中,25.6%(10/39)被认为是 MFICU 和 NICU 可达性脆弱的地区。脆弱和不易达地区的围产儿死亡率没有差异,但脆弱地区的孕产妇死亡率明显高于不易达地区。