Atalar Arife Çimen, Baykan Betül
University of Health Sciences, Istanbul Education and Research Hospital, Department of Neurology, Istanbul, Turkey.
Istanbul University, Istanbul Faculty of Medicine, Department of Neurology and Clinical Neurophysiology, Istanbul, Turkey.
Noro Psikiyatr Ars. 2022 Jan 31;59(1):68-76. doi: 10.29399/npa.27976. eCollection 2022.
Epilepsy is a dynamic and heterogeneous neurological disease, and in long-term studies on prognosis, classically 5 basic patterns (early remission, late remission, relapsing-remitting, worsening, and non-remitting) have been identified. The most frequent pattern was relapsing-remitting course, and factors such as the presence of genetic etiology, rare seizures at the beginning of epilepsy and the absence of psychiatric comorbid diseases were found to be related with this pattern as well as reaching 5 years of remission in the follow-ups. Anti-seizure drug resistance (ASD-R) and factors affecting the presence of this resistance (such as symptomatic etiology, abnormal electroencephalographic findings, having multiple seizure types together, status epilepticus and febrile seizure history) decrease the chance of remission, while idiopathic/genetic etiology, generalized epilepsy, and absence of comorbid diseases seem to be associated with achieving long-term remission. Apart from these basic course patterns, there are some patients with an "atypical prognosis" such as drug-resistant juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME), benign hippocampal sclerosis-related mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (HS-MTLE), and severe childhood epilepsy with centro-temporal spikes (CESTS), in which the pathophysiological mechanisms underlying these patterns have not been clarified despite the suggestions of various hypotheses. The presence of comorbid diseases such as hormonal factors (as in catamenial epilepsy), autoimmune processes, thyroid disorders and metabolic and psychiatric diseases may also cause an atypical prognostic pattern by affecting the course of the disease. In this review, our aim is to provide the clinician with an up-to-date and questioning perspective on the prognostic markers of epilepsy, by examining in detail some specific epilepsy syndromes that may show atypical prognosis as well as the general prognostic features of epilepsy.
癫痫是一种动态且异质性的神经系统疾病,在长期预后研究中,经典地识别出了5种基本模式(早期缓解、晚期缓解、复发-缓解型、病情恶化和未缓解型)。最常见的模式是复发-缓解型病程,发现遗传病因的存在、癫痫发作初期发作稀少以及无精神科合并症等因素与这种模式以及随访中达到5年缓解期有关。抗癫痫药物耐药性(ASD-R)以及影响这种耐药性存在的因素(如症状性病因、脑电图异常结果、同时存在多种发作类型、癫痫持续状态和热性惊厥病史)会降低缓解的几率,而特发性/遗传病因、全身性癫痫以及无合并症似乎与实现长期缓解有关。除了这些基本病程模式外,还有一些患者具有“非典型预后”,如耐药性青少年肌阵挛癫痫(JME)、良性海马硬化相关的内侧颞叶癫痫(HS-MTLE)以及伴有中央颞部棘波的严重儿童癫痫(CESTS),尽管有各种假说提出,但这些模式背后的病理生理机制尚未阐明。激素因素(如月经性癫痫)、自身免疫过程、甲状腺疾病以及代谢和精神疾病等合并症的存在也可能通过影响疾病进程导致非典型预后模式。在本综述中,我们的目的是通过详细研究一些可能显示非典型预后的特定癫痫综合征以及癫痫的一般预后特征,为临床医生提供关于癫痫预后标志物的最新且具有启发性的观点。