Faculty of Medicine of the University of Porto, Porto, Portugal.
Department of Life Sciences of the State University of Bahia, Bahia, Salvador, Brazil.
BMC Med Educ. 2022 Mar 22;22(1):199. doi: 10.1186/s12909-022-03250-9.
A curriculum is a fundamental tool for educators, and teaching bioethics is fundamental to good medical practice. Studies report a lack of consensus on the teaching of bioethics in undergraduate medicine, and a critical issue is that there remain no minimum curricular parameters. This study performed an analysis between the bioethics curricula of the medical schools of Brazil and Portugal and UNESCO's Core Curriculum, in addition to proposing key criteria for designing a core bioethics curriculum.
This is a cross-sectional, descriptive study that analyzes the bioethics curricula of the medical schools in Brazil and in Portugal. The design of the study includes a qualitative summative content analysis-based approach and a quantitative analysis by means of descriptive statistics.
Bioethics is taught in both Brazil and Portugal in a diversified way. The results showed that 65.5% of the medical schools analyzed provided at least the 30-h minimum workload recommended by the UNESCO Core Curriculum. Furthermore, bioethics sporadically offered at the end of the medical program in the vast majority of schools studied.
The most important points to take away from this study are the diversity of the curricular structure of bioethics courses and the lack of formalization of bioethics in the curricula of medical schools in Brazil and Portugal. Given the value of bioethics in clinical practice, we propose that medical schools in Portugal and Brazil update their curricula to encompass minimum criteria, which should be similar to one another and based on common sources, but which should also be tailored to each culture.
课程是教育工作者的基本工具,教授生命伦理学对于良好的医学实践至关重要。研究报告表明,本科医学教育中的生命伦理学教学缺乏共识,一个关键问题是仍然没有最低课程参数。本研究对巴西和葡萄牙医学院的生命伦理学课程与教科文组织核心课程进行了分析,并提出了设计核心生命伦理学课程的关键标准。
这是一项横断面、描述性研究,分析了巴西和葡萄牙医学院的生命伦理学课程。研究设计包括基于定性总结性内容分析方法和通过描述性统计进行的定量分析。
巴西和葡萄牙以多样化的方式教授生命伦理学。结果表明,分析的医学院中有 65.5%提供了至少 30 小时的 UNESCO 核心课程推荐的最低工作量。此外,在大多数研究的学校中,生命伦理学课程在医学项目结束时零星开设。
从这项研究中得出的最重要的几点是生命伦理学课程结构的多样性以及巴西和葡萄牙医学院课程中生命伦理学缺乏正式化。鉴于生命伦理学在临床实践中的重要性,我们建议葡萄牙和巴西的医学院更新其课程,纳入最低标准,这些标准应该彼此相似,基于共同的来源,但也应该适应各自的文化。